Harry F. Byrd Professor of national politics at the university of Virginia; manager of the regimen for Constitutionalism and also Democracy
by Jamin Raskin
U.S. Representative because that Maryland"s 8 hours Congressional district (D); Co-Founder of the Marshall-Brennan Constitutional proficiency Project
Most democratic nations on planet elect their presidents by straight popular vote, yet that was never the American system and also still is not. We usage the so-called “Electoral College” device to select our president, i m sorry today way that 538 Electors drawn from the states and the ar of Columbia speak for the rest of us. This is a complex and non-uniform state-based process, designed—like the U.S. Senate, i beg your pardon was originally composed that Members liked by state legislatures, no the people—to filter windy opinion with a “deliberative” intermediate institution. Yet the Electoral university has developed recurring political conflict over the century and also experienced far-ranging constitutional, legislative, and also political upheaval and revision. Today couple of people would take into consideration the Electoral university to be a “deliberative” body as it was once imagined because the Electors are appointed mechanistically to winners according to vote totals in the states. Return the Electors fulfill in their state resources at a December date set by congress to cast their ballots, in exercise they merely follow the election returns and never conduct substantive conversation or debate around who must be president. Still, the Electors carry out possess the legal prerogative to vote as they wish, and under extraordinary circumstances they can exercise the prerogative to change the intended outcome dictated by popular election returns.
You are watching: Each state has one vote in congress
The colloquially-named Electoral College arises from post II, ar 1, clauses 2 and also 3, i m sorry state that:
"Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the legislature thereof may direct, a number of Electors, equal to the whole variety of Senators and also Representatives come which the State might be entitled in the Congress; but no senator or Representative, or person holding an Office of trust or profit under the United states shall be appointed an Elector.
The congress may determine the Time of chusing the Electors, and also the work on which they shall give their Votes; which job shall it is in the exact same throughout the joined States."
Under the further original provisions of post II, Electors cast ballots not for one candidate because that president yet for two, through the second-place finisher ending up being vice-president. No one initially expected that there would be nationwide parties the nominated candidates and slated a ticket for president and also vice-president. The strange two-vote function nevertheless led virtually immediately to a major political situation in the election of 1800 as soon as Democratic-Republican thomas Jefferson defeated Federalist john Adams 73-65 in the Electoral College but then bound his own nominal to run mate, Aaron Burr, 73-73. The naughty Burr refuse to stand under in the confront of this embarrassing constitutional glitch, thus throwing the procedure into the U.S. Residence of representatives under the so-called “contingent election” steps in which every state’s U.S. House of to represent delegation casts a solitary vote for president and the winner the the majority becomes president. The resulting contingent election in the House ended up being a nightmare that its own once the lame-duck Federalist-controlled Congress took an exhausting 6 days and also 36 ballots to pick Jefferson, who the Federalists ultimately taken into consideration the lesser of two evils.
The most glaring early bugs in the system—the real possibility of ties, the fact that the president and vice-president might represent different political next as had actually happened once Adams and Jefferson offered together in 1796—were ironed out by the Twelfth revised in 1804. But our distinct Electoral College mechanism has continued to shape the country’s politics in an essential ways the both supporters and critics would certainly agree depart from autonomous norms.
Under post II, the says are allotted a number of Electors same to your Congressional delegation, i beg your pardon is the variety of Representatives plus 2 for the Senators, yet the yes, really Electors space appointed according to rules set exclusively by the state legislatures themselves. Today, 48 says appoint all of their Electors top top a “winner take it all” communication from slates provided by the height vote-getter in their statewide renowned election because that president. However two states—Maine and also Nebraska—award the Electors by congressional District and also give their staying two electoral votes to the statewide winner. Historically, there has been one even much more dizzying selection in the systems emerged in every state. In the very first presidential election, five state legislatures—in Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, brand-new Jersey, and South Carolina—themselves simply designated presidential Electors there is no having any popular election at all. In 4 states, the voter elected every one of the Electors. In Virginia, which had ten conference districts, the basic Assembly split the republic into twelve presidential districts and also conducted a renowned election. In succeeding elections, there have been statewide elections, elections of Electors indigenous single-member districts that mirror Congressional districts, elections of Electors native specially designed multi-member districts, poll in which just the Electors’ names appear on the ballot but not the names of the presidential candidates, elections in which the presidential candidates’ names show up on the ballot however not the names of the Electors, and even elections whereby the state legislatures have chosen not to appoint any type of Electors.
All of these variations are allowable under the constitution design. Together the supreme Court composed in McPherson v. Blacker (1892), i beg your pardon rejected a constitutional difficulty to a Michigan law giving for an option of Electors through a ar system, “the appointment and mode of meeting of Electors belong exclusively to the claims under the structure of the unified States.” We have no uniform national device for appointing Electors, which way the legislatures execute not have to consult the general public at all. As soon as members that the Florida legislative in 2000 threatened to abandon the outcomes of the statewide well-known contest and appoint Electors because that a details candidate, the can be fried Court in Bush v. Gore (2000) appeared to endorse their power to perform so by denying that citizens have actually a constitutional appropriate to poll in presidential elections. Together the bulk put it, “The individual citizen has actually no federal constitutional right to vote for Electors for the president of the joined States. . .” once it pertains to presidential elections, the voters room at the mercy the the state legislatures.
Although this lack of procedural uniformity has actually not proven especially controversial, this fact has: the Electoral College has periodically developed winners who clearly lost the national well-known vote come an opponent. In in ~ least 5 presidential elections—1824, 1876, 1888, 2000, and also 2016—the presidential candidate who prevailed in the well-known vote lost in the Electoral College. Because that example, in the disputed election of 2000, Vice chairman Al Gore received over 500,000 an ext votes than Governor George W. Shrub did nationally, yet lost to shrub in the Electoral university by a vote of 266 to 271, ~ the can be fried Court intervened, top top equal defense claims, come halt a Florida can be fried Court order come recount ballots in part counties. Countless people think that the capability to bring the entirety election by capturing this or the state—in our time it has been Florida and also Ohio—increases the likelihood of strategy mischief and also corruption in the electoral process.
Supporters the the Electoral College credit it with preserving vital dimension of state-based federalism in our presidential elections and also argue that it works to guarantee that our Presidents will have actually nationwide support. Critics argue under present circumstances the it in reality consigns many states in the Union to “spectator” standing in presidential elections and drags down voter turnout in these states, reduces the real field of play to fewer than a dozen “swing states,” and dramatically polarizes the nation’s national politics while reducing voter turnout. Proposed constitutional amendments for different plans because that a direct popular election—some through a run-off delivery in the occasion no candidate receive 40 percent in the an initial round—have to date made small headway.
A recent and also unusual plan to work roughly the amendment process and deal with the difficulties of the Electoral university is the National well-known Vote Plan, which began in Maryland in 2007 and has since won support from a dozen other states. The idea is to type an interstate agreement for says to appoint their Electors because that the winner that the national popular vote quite than the winner in every state. Champion of this arrangement assert that it would certainly guarantee that there would certainly be no much more “wrong winners” and that every part of the Union would attract political investment and campaigning by the parties which today quickly abandon large parts the the country to their enemies while taking plenty of other states for granted. Enemies say that the National well-known Vote arrangement actually loss the state-based architecture of the Electoral College, might never be applied if a state reneged on its promise, and is unconstitutional. Offered the proceeding polarization the American politics and background unhappiness through the Electoral College, it seems certain that the National popular Vote plan and also other revolutionary proposals will continue to entice public attention and also debate.