*
" class="w-100">
Southwestern advantage sells textbooks targeted to kindergarteners come high schoolers by walking door-to-door.

photo by gendergeek.org document Photo | The elevation Florida gendergeek.org

With the promise of quick cash do in a summer, it’s simple to view the appeal of multi-level marketing and also direct sales programs. 

It’s even much easier to check out why those suppliers would search for recruits on college campuses complete of unemployed, busy students.

You are watching: Door to door book sales college students


One program, Southwestern Advantage, which sells textbooks, has been the topic of scrutiny by students. The firm recruits in ~ UF job fairs and also at the Reitz Union, working closely with the UF Career relationships Center. Students speak the regime is misleading, predatory and also unethical.

It’s banned from miscellaneous college campuses consisting of Harvard university for “irregular recruiting activities," college of Maryland after ~ students complained that the regimen is misrepresented together a company opportunity quite than a sales job, and also University that Idaho for recruiting in classrooms without university permission.

The program, pitched together a summer internship, adheres to a direct sales service approach, Amy Groom, straight sales leader in ~ Southwestern Advantage, wrote in one email.

College students are sent to various states or countries, often responsible for their very own transportation, wherein they stay with a organize family. The agency operates in all 50 states and also over 20 various countries, follow to Groom. Lock then work day-long shifts, often picking to occupational over 10 hours, whereby they shot to sell textbooks targeted to kindergarteners to high schoolers by going door-to-door, she said. 

Due to COVID-19, the regime has adapted by enforcing face covering, regular temperature checks and also contactless payment. 

There is no early buy-in or offering quota for program members, Groom said. Students keep 40% of the sleeve price from their sales.


Still, follow to the program’s “expectations” brochure, students are typically responsible for paying around $50 a week for housing and also $10 come $20 for the room where weekly Sunday meetings are hosted by Southwestern advantage leaders. Certified dealer must likewise travel to a maintain school prior to the regime where students that have currently been v the program will need to pay $125-150 lodging because that the week.

Despite this, UF works carefully with the company.

Southwestern benefit is provided as a “career education and learning partner” ~ above the bottom that the Career connections Center’s website, together with five other large companies including aerospace copy, group Lockheed martin and big Four accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers. 

This means they salary the school a details amount the money each year, said Ja’Net Glover, an elderly director for career solutions at the UF Career relationships Center. 


gain what you"re reading? get content indigenous The gendergeek.org ceded to your inbox

Southwestern benefit is at this time a “gold level” companion with the CCC. In exchange for $7,500 for the spring 2020 through loss 2020 semesters, the agency is may be to use the CCC’s facilities for information sessions to hold interviews among other privileges, Glover said. They also hold sessions ~ above topics exterior of your brand ,such as goal setup and communication skills.

A in march 2019 Facebook write-up by the CCC shares that Southwestern advantage presented the facility with a certificate recognizing UF together a “2018 global Top 25 Campus.” 

Students top top Reddit, an online conversation forum, report having Southwestern advantage representatives come into their lectures during course time in bespeak to give their pitches and promote the program.

Southwestern benefit can’t pay to speak to students in your classes, Glover said. Instead, student who job-related with the firm or to represent privately arrange with professors to carry out so. 

“I am constantly encouraging our students to ask questions and be certain about her interests so that you’re not misled and also misguided,” Glover said.

CCC employees have been invite to Southwestern advantage workshops and are may be to watch the materials they offer students, Glover said.

“We have actually policies and procedures that protect the university of Florida students, and protect the university,” Glover said. “At any type of point, if our students have involves or complaints around their experience with any type of employer, us take those an extremely seriously.”

Southwestern benefit maintains that is no a multi-level marketing program because recruiters carry out not earn a portion of the proceeds indigenous the world under them. Instead, they obtain a bonus revenue from the firm when they effectively recruit and also train students who go with the program, Groom said.

Still, Southwestern Advantage, a single-level marketing company, operates very an in similar way to one MLM, said Richard Lutz, chair of the UF marketing department.

A multi-level marketing design relies ~ above a direct sales approach, Lutz said. But with one MLM, employees must recruit people and convince them come recruit much more people, receiving a section of the sales from everyone under them.

This differs from an illegal pyramid scheme, which adheres to a similar model, due to the fact that there is an yes, really product gift sold, the said.

“The appeal of these multi-level firms, whether they're legitimate or even if it is they're non legitimate pyramid schemes, is the promise of straightforward money,” Lutz said.

At least 5 separate posts on the UF sugreddit “r/ufl” have actually been make in the previous two year warning versus students involving themselves with the company.

“Southwestern benefit hasn’t offered up and also is currently doing targeted spam end Instagram. Please don’t loss for this crap,” review one write-up that shares picture of the user being sent out a message asking if they were interested in the program.

“It's an extremely sketchy and they are known for having very shady organization practices, some human being call that a scam,” read another. 

Students top top Reddit also complain about similar programs the advertise on campus favor Vector, a direct-sales company that selling cutlery under the brand Cutco. Vector is thought about a single-level sales agency by the much better Business Bureau.

Truth in Advertising, a non-profit organization committed to protecting consumers against deceptive marketing techniques, said college students space a element target for straight sales companies.

A college student’s flexible schedule, social media skills, wide network the friends and family and also desire for money for tuition make them solid candidates. 

Bradley Gilrane, a 21-year-old UF English senior, said he was really close to being “suckered” right into the company’s summer program after he found out around the company through a seminar he saw at Reitz.

“I to be a Mormon for a short period of time. The a entirely different company but has actually the exact same kind that cult feeling to it,” claimed Gilrane. “They're sending out you away so girlfriend can't hit anything the you think is wrong. It's kind of design so you don't have actually an easy method out.”

He stated the firm pitch sound glamorous. Recruiters told that it’d end up being an chance to develop his very own business and find success. It to be framed as though it was a cool internship opportunity, that said.

Gilrane was given worksheets and packets to fill out prior to he can start selling books. When he no get roughly to it, his recruiter, another UF student, request to accomplish with him and tried to persuade him to continue with the program. As soon as Gilrane claimed he would consider doing that the complying with summer instead, his recruiter got upset and also said the if Gilrane backed the end he wouldn’t be allowed to reconsider.

“He to be so angry,” Gilrane said.

Gilrane said he had seen online and heard indigenous others that the agency tells college student they need to try harder if they nothing sell books or that they aren’t passionate around it. His recruiter made similar comments around work ethic and an individual success.

The expectations catalog reinforces this idea.

“You and you alone are at some point responsible for your success in the routine – no your student leader, not your sales manager, not your roommates, not your sales locality or customers” the catalog reads.

“They don't want you to realize that it’s a scam,” Gilrane said. “They don't want children coming back with horror stories around how they shed money.”

According to “The behavioral Economics the Multilevel Marketing,” by Heidi Liu in the Hastings business Law Journal, people are often convinced into joining these businesses since they follow classic beliefs about productivity and entrepreneurship.

“Consultants may be led to focus on unlikely benefits and also to conform to notions that success the seem continual with the “American dream” — even to their financial loss,” Liu composed in the 2018 study.

Nevertheless, students continue to take part in the programs, and also some also enjoy it. 

Maria Sarralde, a 21-year-old UF business management senior, participated in the program for the previous three summers and also has make a an unified $53,000.

Sarralde first found out about the regimen after she filled the end a questionnaire in among her classes. She claimed the agency was transparent indigenous the start.

Sarralde admits the routine is difficult work, speak she regularly worked 12 to 14 hrs a day, but said that was eventually worth it.

See more: Does The Covid Vaccine Make You Infertile, Infertility And Covid

“I’ve viewed a the majority of both an individual and professional growth,” she wrote in an email. “It was absolutely a difficult job the took difficult work and also dedication yet worth every minute that it.”

But Gilrane still no convinced.

“The entirety thing simply seems really nefarious native the outset, i don't think there is an moral bone in it,” Gilrane said. “I don't think that anyone connected with the is fooled by it due to the fact that it's obvious what it is, it's just not noticeable that it's very harmful.”