Joe Biden: "If Trump it s okay his way, Social protection benefits will certainly run the end in just three year from now.”

PolitiFact’s ruling: Mostly False

Here’s why: A brand-new Joe Biden ad paints a bleak photo for Social security under president Donald Trump.

You are watching: Donald trump on social security and medicare

Here’s the complete text indigenous the ad:

"The cook actuary of the social Security management just exit an analysis of Trump"s planned cuts to society Security. Under Trump"s plan, Social security would become permanently depleted by the middle of calendar year 2023. If Trump gets his way, Social protection benefits will certainly run the end in simply three years from now. Don"t let that happen. Joe Biden will defend Social Security."

The vital claim is "if Trump it s okay his way, Social security benefits will run the end in simply three years." Biden is going more than what Trump has described.


The tricky part is discovering what Trump wants to do. He has said two things that are at odds: he wants to defend Social Security, and also he would carry out away through the payroll taxes that keeps Social security going.

Trump’s "way," together of now, is for Congress to to fill in the space so that Social defense remains funded. However there is no clear plan.


To dissect this ad, let’s start with what society Security’s chief actuary said around a "hypothetical" plan.

A letter to Senate Democrats

Sens. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., lining Schumer, D-N.Y., and Ron Wyden, D-Ore., inquiry the society Security management what would take place if ~ above Jan.1, 2021, the payroll tax went to zero v no other transforms in the law.

The social Security part of the taxes is 12.4% the payroll, split equally between workers and employers, or paid completely by the self-employed. The money goes into the program’s Old Age and Survivors Insurance to trust Fund.

Nixing that would placed a feet in the 2021 social Security spending plan of $1.03 trillion, chief actuary Stephen Goss claimed in his letter to the senators. That would be over 90% that the program’s revenues.

But the regime would proceed to pay benefits, illustration down its to trust fund.

"We estimate that Old Age and Survivors insurance allowance Trust fund reserves would come to be permanently depleted by the center of calendar year 2023," Goss wrote.

Goss said that without any change in the law, the program’s hands would be tied. Conference sets benefits, the society Security administration must pay them, and it can’t borrow come cover a shortfall.

"Under this theoretical legislation, advantage obligations could not it is in met after ~ the depletion that the asset reserves and elimination of payroll taxes," he wrote.

In his letter, Goss provided the hatchet "hypothetical legislation" ripe times. And also he provided that "I to be not mindful that anyone has proposed the theoretical legislation girlfriend describe."

So, there is no plan. However Trump has targeted the payroll tax without a clear route to instead of it.

Bold promises and mixed messages

The an obstacle of understanding Trump’s words on the payroll tax is that, aside from the short-lived deferral the taxes, they are untethered come a clean plan.

For the many part, there’s been a pattern of Trump speak he would finish the payroll tax and his top advisors speak he didn’t typical it.


It began Aug. 8 when Trump unveiled a four-month payroll tax holiday that would last from September with December, an effort to administer financial relief throughout the coronavirus pandemic.

"If i win, I might extend and terminate," trump card said. "In various other words, I’ll extend it past the end of the year and also terminate the tax."

Since the taxation holiday covered only the worker part of 6.2%, Trump’s words could have meant either ending the entire tax, or just the worker’s portion.

The following day, White House financial chief Larry Kudlow said CNN Trump’s arrangement was minimal to forgiving the four months of deferred tax dollars.

The one clear plan was that the administration wanted conference to backfill the shed revenues native the taxation holiday — at this time estimated at about $80 exchange rate — v money from basic revenues.

But Trump went on to repeat that he planned come "terminate the tax" beyond December in press briefings on Aug. 10 and Aug. 12.

Pressed to explain how he would pay because that Social defense without the payroll tax, Trump was vague.

Trump: "We’re acquisition it the end of the general Fund. And also what we’ll carry out —"

Reporter: "But that would certainly incur huge deficits."

Trump: "Yeah, what fine be doing is, if we carry out that, we’ll acquire it approved, in that case, by Congress. And also we’ll take it the money from various other places, various other than — we will certainly not take it native Social defense in any way shape or form."

Reporter: "How execute you fund it from the basic Fund, once the General money just incurred a blame of $2.8 trillion?"


Trump: "You’re right, however we’re going to have actually tremendous growth."

When Fox News asked him around his plan Aug. 23, trump card said, "It will have actually no influence on society Security. We"re taking it the end of the basic fund. The comes out of the basic fund. If anything happens, we would replace it immediately."

In his accept speech, trump never stated the payroll tax and also referred come Social security one time, saying, "We will safeguard Medicare and Social Security."

The Trump project said the there is no arrangement to eliminate the payroll tax, and, with Trump’s commitment to preserving Social security through basic revenues, the program’s trust money would no run out of money.

Our ruling

The Biden advertisement said, "If Trump gets his way, Social security benefits will run out in just three year from now."

The Social security chief actuary go say that if the social Security portion of the payroll taxes were eliminated, the routine would run out of money in 3 years. Absent any solution by Congress, the regime would be unable to pay benefits.

But the chief actuary likewise said he was unaware that anyone plan to finish the payroll tax. The Trump project says over there is no setup to carry out so.

Trump has said he desires to terminate the tax. The would placed the routine under great financial stress. Yet Trump claimed he would look to congress to maintain the program and draw on general revenues — possibly in excess of $1 trillion a year — to replenish any kind of lost funds.


Overall, Trump’s comments suggest he desires a fully funded Social security program, but he doesn’t desire the taxes the pay for it. This is contradictory, yet it doesn’t median he wants Social protection to operation out of money in 3 years.

We rate the claim Mostly False.

See more: Do I Need Antivirus For Ipad Do You Need To Install An Antivirus? If So, Why?

PolitiFact Texasis a partnership of the Austin American-gendergeek.org, Houston Chronicle and the san Antonio Express-News to aid you discover the reality in Texas politics.

Sources

Joe Biden, Depleted, Sept. 1, 2020

Social security Administration, chef actuary’s letter come Senate Democrats, Aug. 24, 2020

White House, Remarks by president Trump in push Briefing, Aug. 8, 2020

White House, Remarks by chairman Trump in press Briefing, Aug. 10, 2020

White House, Remarks by president Trump in push Briefing, Aug. 12, 2020

Fox News, Steve Hilton interview v Donald Trump, Aug. 23, 2020

PBS, White House financial adviser Larry Kudlow: Republican convention speech, Aug. 25, 2020