Share every sharing options for: Trump claimed he wouldn’t cut Medicaid, social Security, and also Medicare. His 2020 budget cuts every 3.

In 2015, presidential candidate Donald trump card pledged he i will not ~ cut significant entitlement programs. Tom Brenner/Getty photos
chairman Donald Trump’s 2020 budget breaks one of his biggest project promises come voters: the he would leave Medicaid, social Security, and Medicare untouched.

You are watching: Does trump want to cut medicare

“I’m no going to cut Social Security choose every various other Republican and also I’m no going to reduced Medicare or Medicaid,” Trump called the daily Signal, a conservative publication affiliated with the legacy Foundation, in 2015.

Over the next 10 years, Trump’s 2020 spending plan proposal aims to invest $1.5 trillion much less on medicaid — instead allocating $1.2 sunshine in a block-grant program to states — $25 billion much less on society Security, and also $845 billion much less on Medicare (some of that is reclassified come a various department). Your intentions space to cut benefits under Medicaid and also Social Security. The impact on Medicare is much more complicated, i m sorry I’ll gain into a little later.

Over time, the Trump administration tried come whittle down the president’s promise to simply Social Security and also Medicare. Office the Management and also Budget Deputy manager Russ Vought claimed Monday, march 11, that Trump is “keeping his meeting to american by no making changes to Medicare and Social Security.” however even that is no true.

Like “every various other Republican,” Trump has actually repeatedly proposed and also supported cutting these programs. The White residence did not respond to a request for comment.

How trump card is proposing an altering Medicare, Medicaid, and also Social Security

When it concerns Medicare, the White House has been really clear: “He’s not cutting Medicare in this budget,” Vought said. “What we space doing is placing forward reforms that reduced drug prices. Since Medicare pays a very huge of medicine prices in this country, has actually the affect of finding savings. We are likewise finding waste, fraud, and abuse.”

Here’s what’s in reality happening: This budget plan proposes detect $845 billion in savings end 10 year from Medicare together we recognize it. But $269 exchange rate of that figure is reclassified under the department of Health and also Human Services, happen the Medicare cut to $575 billion. As explained, the administration says it will achieve these price reductions through targeting wasteful spending and also provider payments and also lowering prescription drug costs.

The Committee because that a Responsible federal Budget, which advocates for fiscal responsibility, estimates that 85 percent of these cuts will come from reductions in provider payments, 5 percent would come indigenous policies roughly medical malpractice, and 11 percent would certainly come indigenous reducing drug prices through the Medicare component D program. Medicare component D is the only area of these reforms that can raise out-of-pocket medicine prices for some while lowering it because that others. Otherwise, premiums, deductibles, and also copays would largely be left unaffected.

Unsurprisingly, the Federation of American Hospitals is no a pan of this part of Trump’s spending plan proposal. In a statement, they dubbed the revolutionary “devastating because that seniors.” an ext surprisingly, together Axios’s Sam Baker points out, this reforms space pretty comparable to policies Barack Obama propose in 2012 that Republicans panned.

But once it comes to Trump’s proposed transforms to Medicaid and society Security, the will is unambiguous: These room cuts come benefits.

The 2020 budget’s Medicaid revolutionary include adding work requirements and also repealing medical allowance expansion and also one that the most successful policies within the Affordable treatment Act. Medicaid expansion diminished the uninsured price by an ext than 6 percent in states that spreading the policy; it proceeds to show far better health outcomes and also is famous in conservative states. However Trump is envisioning transforming Medicaid altogether; his budget proposes transforming the current pay-as-needed mechanism to a block grant, where states are provided a capped lump-sum money that doesn’t prosper with enhanced need or rising costs. The budget proposes a $1.2 trillion “Market-Based Health treatment Grant.”

In isolation, the Medicaid budget plan cuts amount come $1.5 sunshine over 10 years, yet looked in ~ in the context of the brand-new block grant as well the work-related requirements and ACA cuts, the cut round the end to around $777 exchange rate — which might leave millions an ext uninsured.

The budget additionally continues an assault on Social Security, including to a routine that gives assistance come those who have disabilities that stop them from gift in the workforce. In all, the cut to Social protection amount to $25 billion over the next 10 years, cutting roughly $10 billion from the society Security disability Insurance (SSDI) program, i m sorry the management says will be found through cutting down on fraud — a typical conservative talking point.

Trump broke this promise from the beginning

This is trump card on the project trail in 2015:

I to be the first & just potential GOP candidate come state there will be no cut to social Security, Medicare & Medicaid. Huckabee copied me.

— Donald J. Trump (

Trump’s budgets — and the policies he has actually supported approximately health treatment — and also government security in congress reflect the opposite. Few of this have the right to be attributed come Trump’s appointed budget chief Mick Mulvaney; the former Congress member that was part of the ultraconservative liberty Caucus has actually long rallied because that cutting Medicare, social Security, and Medicaid.

In fact, Mulvaney once bragged to a Politico reporter the he tricked Trump into accepting a proposal to cut Social defense by phone call SSDI just disability insurance — turn it to the chairman as basic welfare reform. The idea has been in every single one that Trump’s budget plan proposals to Congress because the president pertained to office.

Then there was the Republican Obamacare repeal push; every invoice proposed substantial cuts to medicaid in order to pay for tax cuts elsewhere. Trump supported every iteration the Republicans’ Obamacare repeal-and-replace bills. He even held a party for home Republicans in the White residence Rose Garden as soon as the lower chamber the Congress directly passed a proposal that slashed much more than $800 billion from Medicaid end 10 years.

See more: Groundhog Day 2021: Did The Woodchuck See His Shadow ? Punxsutawney Phil Says Early Spring

Republican lawmakers have actually long argued that spending about mandatory program that consist of 70 percent that the federal budget — choose Medicare and Social security — needs to be reined in in stimulate to tackle the national debt. Trump drew red tape approximately those programs, as well as Medicaid, on the campaign trail in 2015 because they are very popular commonwealth programs.

Now his policy positions approximately those programs rest from that promise.

Will you support’s explanatory journalism?

Millions rotate to to recognize what’s happening in the news. Our mission has actually never been more an important than the is in this moment: to empower v understanding. Financial contribute from our readers are a an important part of sustaining our resource-intensive work and assist us save our journalism cost-free for all. Please take into consideration making a donation to this particular day to assist us save our work free for all.