The knife trapped in stone, just to it is in freed through the forceful tight of a future king, is an important part of the King Arthur mythology. The concern of whether there’s historical basis for Arthur in the mists of chaotic Dark eras Britain has haunted many historians, writers, and also treasure seekers. Bits and also pieces the the Arthur legend have actually been analyzed infinite to see if some real human being or place can fit.

You are watching: Does the sword in the stone exist

In a variation of the story, Merlin foretold that only a true king was worthy to draw the sword, and when a boy, Arthur, is the one that succeeds in act it, the reveals self to be the son of the brave king Uther Pendragon. That sword then i do not care Arthur’s powerful weapon, referred to as Excalibur.

King Arthur pulling out the sword in the stone.

But what if the catalyst for the tale of the knife in the stone comes no from England yet from Italy, and also the evidence of that can be uncovered in a 12th century rock still thrust right into bedrock in Tuscany?

Montesiepi chapel in Tuscany. Photo by Adrian Michael CC BY-SA 3.0

The sword in the stone of Saint Galgano deserve to be viewed today, in the Montesiepi chapel southwest that Siena. The was lengthy a curiosity: only the hilt, wooden grip and a few inches that the 3 foot long blade space visible come be watched in the chapel of a Cistercian abbey. The story was that it to be thrust into the rock by an Italian knight, Galgano Guidotti, after that renounced war to become a hermit in 1180.


Interior that Montesiepi chapel, through the knife in the stone under the clear case. Photograph by Superchilum CC BY-SA 4.0

For year the knife was doubt of being some sort of fake. However, recent scientific tests dealt a surprise to skeptics. The metal of the sword was evidenced to it is in from the 12th century.


Rotonda the Montesiepi chapel, with the sword in the rock below. Photo by cisko66 CC by 3.0

“Dating metal is a very an overwhelming task, yet we can say the the ingredient of the metal and the style are compatible through the era of the legend,” claimed Luigi Garlaschelli, of the college of Pavia, in an interview through The Guardian. “We have succeeded in refuting those who keep that that is a current fake.”


Altar of Montesiepi chapel. Picture by Superchilum CC BY-SA 4.0

Not just is the knife from the middle ages era however ground-penetrating radar analysis revealed the beneath the knife there is a cavity that can be a funeral recess, maybe containing a body. “To know much more we’d need to excavate,” stated Garlaschelli.


Sword in the stone at Montesiepi chapel, mountain Gagnano. Picture by cisko66 CC by 3.0

The Italian scholastic Mario Moiraghi created a book suggesting that the Arthurian legend of the rock was influenced by the Tuscany sword. A 13th century English book about Merlin and the sword obviously came after the presence of the Italian knife in stone, together did Malory’s Le Morte d’Arthur in the 14th century. However, Geoffrey of Monmouth wrote around Arthur, Merlin, and Excalibur, dubbed Caliburnus (or Caliburn), in Historia, completed in 1138.

Moiraghi claimed in an interview, “The sword which, having actually being plunged into the rock becomes a cross; this is a true symbol of the Christian life — the revolution of violence right into love.”

In the very same chapel room two mummified hands; scientific experimentation has revealed that they too date to the 12th century. Follow to legend, anyone that tries come steal the sword in the Tuscany chapel would have his arms ripped off.

The knight, Galgano, was the boy of a feudal lord recognized for his arrogance and also violence once he had a vision of the Archangel Michael inviting that to readjust his life.

See more: Down These Mean Streets Full Text, Down These Mean Streets

Galgano supposedly chose that the should end up being a hermit. Together he climbed the hill where he would devote his life to contemplation, a voice told him he had actually to leaving all traces that worldly sin, come which the saint replied, “It would certainly be simpler to cut a stone with this sword to carry out that.”

Related Article: Excalibur: the knife of King Arthur is a central theme of legends, contradictions, and contemporary findings

When Galgano grounding his sword in the absent to prove his point, the knife sank smoothly. It got in the rock together if the were together soft together butter, the story goes. Galgano was a hermit for the rest of his life. Four years after his fatality he was canonized and a chapel was built approximately the sword.

Nancy Bilyeau, a former staff editor in ~ Entertainment Weekly, roll Stone, and also InStyle, has actually written a trilogy of historical thrillers for Touchstone Books. Her brand-new book, The Blue, is a spy story collection in the 18th-century porcelain world. For much more information, go to