Nationally, electrocution is outdated. But several condemned guys put to death in Tennessee have chosen it. Nicholas Sutton is scheduled to be the fifth tonight.

You are watching: Does texas use the electric chair


Send any kind of friend a story

As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to provide each month. Anyone can read what you share.



Death row inmates in Tennessee can choose the technique the state will usage to end their lives. Increasingly, lock are selecting the electrical chair.Credit...Mark Humphrey/Associated Press

NASHVILLE — Nicholas Sutton, like other death row inmates in Tennessee, has actually a selection in exactly how the state will end his life.

The default, as collection by state law, would be a collection of injections, one to sedate him, complied with by rather that would certainly paralyze him and also stop his heart. Yet Mr. Sutton, like four other inmates executed before him in Tennessee because 2018, has chosen the state’s various other option: 2 cycles of 1,750 volts that electricity.

Nationally, the electric chair is a method of the past; no various other state has actually used it because 2013. Yet inmate advocates and also lawyers speak the condemned men in Tennessee are picking electrocution due to the fact that they are afraid being frozen in place and also feeling extreme discomfort while drugs occupational to kill them.

In Ohio, a commonwealth judge freshly wrote that component of the state’s lethal injection protocol is akin to waterboarding, and botched procedures in other states have left males writhing in agony.


“When every little thing works perfectly, it’s about 14 minutes of pain and also horror,” claimed Stephen Kissinger, one assistant federal neighborhood defender who has actually represented Mr. Sutton and other fatality row inmates. “Then, castle look at electrocution, and also how lengthy does the take?”

Tennessee joined other states more than 2 decades earlier in transforming to lethal injection together the primary technique for executions, v lawmakers the town hall it together a visibly calmer and less violent different to electrocution.

But that view has actually been challenged in recent years, together errors and also problematic executions, including one in Oklahoma in 2014 in i beg your pardon an inmate regained consciousness, have obtained widespread notice. Plenty of pharmaceutical suppliers have also made the more an overwhelming for states to gain the appropriate drugs, no wanting them associated with ending lives.

The fatality penalty, in general, has been ~ above the decrease in the united States, v seven claims carrying the end 22 executions in 2019, the second-lowest number since 1991. Last year, new Hampshire ended up being the 21st state, and the last in brand-new England, to abandon capital punishment. And a year ago, Ohio paused executions when state officials considered a new lethal injection protocol ~ the drugs might not be obtained and also a commonwealth judge uncovered that the an approach could reason an inmate “severe pain and also needless suffering.”

“Ohio is not going to execute someone under mine watch when a commonwealth judge has uncovered it to be cruel and unusual punishment,” Gov. Mike DeWine, a Republican, claimed last year.


But various other states have actually doubled down. Critical week, state public official in Oklahoma announced that lethal injection deaths would certainly resume after a five-year hiatus and also a collection of botched executions.

In Tennessee, the protocol calls for the injection of three drugs: midazolam, a sedative; vecuronium bromide, i m sorry paralyzes the inmate; and also potassium chloride, which stops the heart. Dorinda L. Carter, a spokeswoman for the State room of Correction, detailed that “lethal injection has actually repeatedly been upheld as constitutional in Tennessee.”

The state’s Republican governor, invoice Lee, has also maintained his assistance of the death penalty, speak in an interview through The linked Press published in December that he to trust the punishment remains “appropriate because that those most heinous of crimes.”

Some medical experts compete that lethal injection test the constitutional boundaries on cruel punishment. Joel B. Zivot, an combine professor of anesthesiology and also surgery in ~ Emory University, claimed the sedative offered in the three-drug cocktail does no inure the inmates come pain and that the paralytic masks the torment they are enduring.


“You simply don’t check out much,” Dr. Zivot said. “You view a person lying there.” He included that it creates an impression that the inmates are simply “falling asleep and also dying.” Instead, that said, the medicine can cause their lung to fill v fluid, asphyxiating them, and also makes castle feel favor they are burning.

Dr. Zivot, who has actually evaluated Mr. Sutton, together with other inmates top top Tennessee’s death row, claimed the inmates are regularly in poor health, through a litany of medical problems, including diabetes, hypertension, high cholesterol and also pulmonary ailments.


“With respect to the rightness or wrongness, ns agnostic,” Dr. Zivot stated of resources punishment. But, that added, “You may say, who cares? It’s simply an inmate who has actually killed someone, and we fan them nothing. Some human being may think that, however the constitution states otherwise.”

Nearly four years had passed there is no an inmate being placed to fatality in Tennessee as soon as state lawmakers, in 1998, included lethal injection as a technique of execution. Two years later, it ended up being the state’s major method. However according come state law, inmates who were condemned come death before 1999 are enabled to choose between lethal injection and also electrocution.

Of the 52 inmates ~ above Tennessee’s fatality row, more than half received their sentences prior to the cutoff, follow to data from the state’s department of Correction.

In 2007, Daryl Keith Holton, that confessed come killing 4 children, including three of his own, was the an initial inmate to be enforcement by electrocution in the state since 1960. Since 2018, four inmates have actually been put to death by the electrical chair.

The most recent was Lee Hall, that was executed in December because that killing his former girlfriend, Traci Crozier, by dousing she in gasoline and setting her top top fire. A helmet through a sponge soaked in saline systems was placed on his head, and also a dark shroud was attached to it.

“I think people can find out forgiveness and love and make the civilization a far better place,” Mr. Hall, 53, said prior to being win by a to explode of electricity, i m sorry caused steam or smoke to emanate native his head, witnesses called the news media.

Afterward, Stacie Wooten, the victim’s sister, stated Mr. Hall’s death had carried a measure up of consolation. “Our family’s peace have the right to begin, but an additional family’s hell needs to begin,” she said reporters, follow to The Tennessean newspaper in Nashville.


Mr. Sutton, 58, was sentenced to fatality for his authorized in the death of Carl Estep, an additional inmate in the prison where Mr. Sutton, that was 23 at the time, to be incarcerated. He had actually been convicted of first-degree murder for knocking unconscious his grandmother, who had actually raised him, and throwing her into a river. He received two various other life sentence after he confessed to death a pair that men, John large and Charles Almon.

In an appeal for clemency, Mr. Sutton’s lawyers illustrated his revolution over an ext than 35 year in prison. The mother of a fellow inmate who had actually untreated many sclerosis said Mr. Sutton had actually comforted her son and also even brought him, lock said. Corrections officers additionally said castle “owed your lives” come him for rescuing them native being struck by various other inmates.

“He put my safety and well-being over his own,” one correction official, Tony Eden, created in an op-ed published in The Tennessean, whereby he also called Mr. Sutton the “most rehabilitated inmate ns have ever known.”

“Simply put,” that added, “the prison will certainly be more secure with Sutton offer life 보다 it would certainly be if that is executed.”

Mr. Sutton additionally sought to placed off his execution through arguing, among other things, that he had been improperly bound in front of jurors when on trial. But the Tennessee can be fried Court rubbish his claims, speak in a ruling last Friday that “Mr. Sutton has failed come prove a likelihood the success top top the merits of the lawsuit in both matters.”

With his execution booked for Thursday night, Mr. Sutton was relocated on Tuesday into fatality watch at the Riverbend Maximum protection Institution, a facility in Nashville positioned in a crook of the Cumberland river that houses Tennessee’s fatality row because that men.

See more: Does Smoking Make Canker Sores Worse, Do You Guys Smoke If You Have A Canker Sore

He was put under 24-hour observation in a cabinet adjoining the execution chamber, allowed to have actually his toiletries, 12 sheets that stationery, 3 stamped envelopes and also a pencil the he have to return come a correctional officer whenever he isn’t making use of it. There, that awaited the governor’s decision on even if it is to lug out his execution, which came Wednesday.

“After cautious consideration that Nicholas Sutton’s inquiry for clemency and a thorough testimonial of the case,” Mr. Lee claimed in a statement, “I am upholding the sentence the the State the Tennessee and will no be intervening.”