Nine objections of college Restorative righteousness

Some comes to come native misunderstanding. Others space legitimate challenges.

posted March 7, 2019 | the review by Jessica Schrader

What room the objections of restorative righteousness in the college context?

This is an essential question for any school or institution district considering occurring a systemic restorative response to conflicts and also rule violations. Listed below I perform (and answers to) few of the criticisms I have heard the many over the past couple of years. In the case of the last four, these are pertains to I myself have, as someone that supports institutions in occurring restorative systems.

You are watching: Does restorative justice work in schools

1. The takes as well long. This criticism usually refers to the fact that the preparation and also actual dialogue have the right to eat up a significant amount that time, sometimes (if over there are countless individuals involved) as numerous as number of hours. Punitive discipline commonly takes less time, despite it need to be provided that many schools do connect in a time-intensive investigation process that have the right to either be systematized or eliminated with a restorative system. However even if RJ takes much longer to bring out, come the level that that is more likely to lead to satisfying outcomes, the time saved by avoiding future contact with the so-called technique system deserve to make RJ much much more time-efficient than the alternative.


2. The is too emotionally draining. Well, the true that a circle can feel draining, but it’s also true that countless students, teachers, and staff room invigorated through circles due to the fact that they often see each various other in brand-new ways and often feel more connected afterward. Movement is practically always invigorating. What has tendency to be yes, really draining space ongoing problems that feel “stuck.” RJ gives a way to obtain unstuck. I wrote much more about this here.

3. Teachers need to be teaching, no doing, RJ. it is essential (especially for older grades) to have separate spaces and times for learning and also for conflict. In ~ the exact same time, once there is problem in the classroom, it requirements to be responded to or it will certainly escalate. The an answer can it is in a setup to engage much more deeply at a later time but there does need to be a response. Restorative practices provide teachers with tools come respond in methods that meet both their students’ needs and also their own.

4. Restorative justice doesn’t have actually accountability. If accountability is identified as punishment, this might be true, though countless schools are progressively utilizing a hybrid model that contains both punitive and also restorative elements. Yet accountability is part of the restorative process, too. It’s just conceptualized differently. Rather than being equated with punishment, in restorative justice, accountability take away the form of self-responsibility and also various agreements design to repair harm and make things right. This kind of accountability is not soft. To the contrary, it is not inexplicable for also those who are incarcerated for lengthy periods come report the dialogue v those lock harmed was the hardest point they"ve ever before had to do.


A well-designed, well-functioning restorative system contains documentation of agreements and ways to examine in top top them.

5. Agreements made in restorative procedures are no followed. This is one of the challenges of creating a functional restorative system. A well-designed, well-functioning device will encompass documentation the agreements and ways to examine that they space either being brought out or alternate reparative actions room done instead. Agreements not being adhered to is feedback that the restorative mechanism is not working optimally and also the alters may be needed.

6. Restorative justice doesn’t work. It’s essential for both adults and students in institutions to it is in clear around the objectives of restorative justice. If adults see it as yet one more (perhaps more gentle) means of controlling student behavior, then ns would mean students come resent and also resist together attempts at regulate as lock resent and also resist punitive responses. If, however, both adults and students see restorative justice together a way of share power and also collaborating come build, maintain, and, as soon as necessary, repair relationships, climate the data show that restorative justice walk work and “not working” in a certain school is feedback the the current system needs to it is in tweaked.


In a healthy restorative system, joining is always voluntary. It is not vital for every chair to it is in filled.

7. Restorative justice areas an unfair expectation top top victims/survivors to talk to those that harmed them. The is necessary that no one is required to take part in a restorative process if castle don’t want to execute so. That is also important to know that those who have actually been harmed often want to carry out so because they desire those who did the harm to understand the affect of your actions or they want to have dialogue the creates conditions for the injury to stop.

8. Restorative justice places an unfair expectation on victims/survivors to pardon those who harmed them (especially in the context of either sexual assault or actions regarded as racist). the is necessary that nobody is make to believe that they need to forgive. Forgiveness might happen but it’s no a goal of restorative justice. The objectives are often defined as common understanding and also agreements draft to address unmet needs identified during the mutual expertise stage. In cases of sexual or racialized harm, restorative responses are an especially tricky. This is a situation study around what it might look like, adhering to one such incident.

9. Restorative righteousness is no actually implemented restoratively. Whether we are mindful of it or not, us all have actually a high value for congruence. We can not prefer an authoritarian, top-down approach, but in a context that explicitly values hierarchy and control (as schools regularly do), we have tendency to go in addition to it. Restorative justice, however, is draft to it is in community-owned. The is draft to it is in a room with mutual power whereby everyone has actually a voice. That is therefore specifically important that it is enforced collaboratively and, an ext generally, in means that room congruent through its core principles. As soon as either the process itself or the technique through i m sorry the college designed the restorative device are forced on people rather than created with them, over there is likely to be an extensive resentment and also resistance.

See more: Did The Original Coca Cola Have Coke In It, Cocaine In Coca


Mikhail Lyubansky, Ph.D., teaches in the department of Psychology at the university of Illinois in ~ Urbana-Champaign. The teaches, studies, and also writes around race relations, conflict, and also restorative justice.