Several Republican presidential candidates have declared that Planned Parenthood is “profiting” native abortions. Yet the full, unedited video clip they cite as proof shows a to plan Parenthood executive consistently saying that clinics desire to cover your costs, no make money, once donating fetal organization from abortions for clinical research.

You are watching: Does planned parenthood sell baby parts fact check

Four experts in the ar of human being tissue procurement said us the price selection discussed in the video — $30 come $100 every patient — represents a reasonable fee. “There’s no method there’s a benefit at that price,” claimed Sherilyn J. Sawyer, the manager of Harvard University and also Brigham and also Women’s Hospital’s “biorepository.”

Republicans do their claims following the relax of a privately recorded video showing Deborah Nucatola, the senior director of clinical services at Planned Parenthood, discussing the procurement of fetal tissues when conducting abortions. The edited video, exit July 14 by an anti-abortion group referred to as the facility for medical Progress, leaves the impression that Nucatola is talking about Planned Parenthood affiliates making money indigenous fetal tissue. But the edited video ignores other things Nucatola stated that contradict the idea.

The Videos, Edited and Unedited

At one allude in the unedited video (which was likewise released through the group), Nucatola says: “Affiliates space not looking to make money by act this. They’re feather to offer their patients and simply make it not affect their bottom line.”

Nucatola additionally says, “No one’s walking to check out this as a money making thing.” and also at one more point, she says, “Our goal, like I said, is to give patients the alternative without impacting ours bottom line. The message is this should not be viewed as a brand-new revenue stream, due to the fact that that’s no what that is.”

The footage was videotaped secretly during a lunch conference on July 25, 2014, between Nucatola and two world posing together employees of a agency looking come procure fetal tissue for research study purposes.

While eat a salad and also drinking red wine, she casually discusses i m sorry tissues room valued by researchers and also how to keep those tissues if conducting abortions. To plan Parenthood president Cecile Richards has actually apologized because that Nucatola’s “tone” and also manner that speaking, which home Speaker john Boehner condemned as “cavalier” in calling for a conference investigation.

In the edited video, Nucatola says the cost for fetal organization specimens was between $30 and $100, “depending on the facility and also what’s involved.” She characterized “specimen” as, “one case. One patient.”

Republicans have focused on those comments, characterizing the practice as a means to benefit off abortion:

Rick Perry, July 14: The video showing a planned Parenthood employee selling the body components of aborted children is a psychic reminder that the organization’s penchant because that profiting off the tragedy the a damaged human life.

Rand Paul, July 14: … a video clip showing ’s optimal doctor describing how she performs late-term abortions to sell body parts for profit!

Carly Fiorina, July 14: This latest news is tragic and outrageous. This isn’t about “choice.” It’s around profiting ~ above the fatality of the unborn while informing women it’s around empowerment.

Nucatola’s comment, though, isn’t proof that planned Parenthood or the affiliates are selling “body parts” or fetal organization for profit. The full video clip shows that after Nucatola mentions the $30 to $100, she explains how those quantities would be reimbursement for prices related come handling and transportation the the tissues. Nucatola talks around “space issues” and whether shipping would be involved.

Stafford, July 15: Planned Parenthood and also their pendant in the media room willing to say noþeles to protect their taxpayer funded abortions and also profiteering from offering aborted fetuses. They want to argue about what main they death a child or how much they execute or perform not profit? those blatantly obvious is that Planned Parenthood is do the efforts to distract from your extremist positions and also immoral “business.”

Sawyer, July 20: In reality, $30-100 most likely constitutes a loss for . The costs connected with collection, processing, storage, and inventory and also records management for specimens are really high. Most hospitals will provide tissue blocks from surgical actions (ones no longer needed because that clinical purposes, and also without identity) because that research, and also cost recuperate for your time and effort in the range of $100-500 per case/block. In the kingdom of tissues for research $30-100 is completely reasonable and normal fee.

Jim Vaught, chairman of the International society for Biological and Environmental Repositories and also formerly the deputy manager of the nationwide Cancer Institute’s Office that Biorepositories and Biospecimen Research, told united state in an email that “$30 to $100 per sample is a reasonable fee for clinical to work to recover their prices for giving tissue.” In fact, that said, the expenses to a clinic are often much higher, but most to work that provide this kind of tissue have “no intention of totally recovering  costs, much less making a profit.”

Nucatola does do one declare in the unedited video clip that says to doubters that part clinics would be comfortable with a payment the was slightly an ext than their prices for providing the tissue. “I think for affiliates, in ~ the finish of the day, castle a nonprofit, they simply don’t desire to — they desire to rest even. And if they have the right to do a little much better than rest even, and do so in a means that appears reasonable, they’re happy to perform that,” Nucatola says.

But instantly after this statement, Nucatola walk on to say: “Really your bottom heat is, they want to break even. Every penny they conserve is just pennies they provide to one more patient. To administer a company the patient wouldn’t get.” to plan Parenthood told us that she may have been referring to more general operations of the clinics.

*
Nucatola repeatedly talks about affiliates only wanting to carry out a organization to your patients, who elect to donate the organization for medical research, and not having that service affect their bottom lines. She says that it’s “not a brand-new revenue present the affiliates space looking at” and also that “nobody must be ‘selling’ tissue. That’s simply not the score here.” She claims some affiliates can donate the tissue for free.

Nucatola also discusses to plan Parenthood clinics’ interactions with a organization procurement firm called StemExpress. The company’s website says that partnering through StemExpress have the right to be “financially profitable” for a clinic — a allude that some conservative websites have actually singled out. But this also does no constitute evidence that planned Parenthood is profiting in such a way.

StemExpress, which offers other varieties of organization aside from fetal tissue, did no respond to our request for clarification top top profitability. The did relax a explain on that website expressing pride in its occupational to development research and also saying the complies “with every laws.”

According to one more tissue procurement company called progressed Bioscience Resources, which has provided fetal organization to researcher in a number of federally sponsor studies, the prices mentioned in the video are reasonable. Linda Tracy, ABR’s president, told us in an e-mail that “t is difficult to decide the exact cost of organization acquisition due to the plenty of variables involved,” together as the place of the facility, the specific requests native researchers and any special managing that is required. She said, however, that “$30 to $100 is in ~ a comparable variety of what ABR pays for reimbursement of costs.”

At one point in the video, Nucatola speak the “buyers” (the gibbs purporting to represent a fetal organization procurement company are defined as “buyers” in a transcript provided by the facility for clinical Progress) that affiliates wouldn’t do decisions around whether to work with a tissue study organization based upon money. “You could call them up and also say, ‘I’ll pay you dual the money,’ and they’re almost more inclined come say no, since it’s going to look bad. … To them, this is no a organization they have to be make money from, it’s something lock should be able to offer this to their patients, in a means that doesn’t impact them.”

She then suggests that these “buyers” might have the ability to compete with other companies by providing extra services, such as acquisition tissue the clinics would otherwise need to dispose that themselves.

In a statement on that is website, to plan Parenthood safeguarded its affiliates’ practice of fetal tissue donation as “standard throughout the medical field”:

Planned Parenthood, July 14: At numerous of our wellness centers, we help patients who want to donate organization for scientific research, and also we execute this just like every other high-quality health treatment provider go — through full, ideal consent native patients and also under the highest possible ethical and legal standards. Over there is no financial benefit for organization donation because that either the patient or because that Planned Parenthood. In some instances, actual costs, such together the expense to deliver tissue come leading research study centers, space reimbursed, i m sorry is standard across the clinical field.

Richards, the planned Parenthood president, claimed in a video response come the controversy: “The allegation the Planned Parenthood earnings in any method from organization donation is no true.”

On July 21, the center for clinical Progress exit a second, comparable video, again featuring a discussion with a to plan Parenthood official in a restaurant. The numbers mentioned in the edited video are comparable to what Nucatola said. The official, mar Gatter, quotes a rate of $75 per specimen, and also says she was thinking of saying $50. The discussion only will $100 since the “buyers” in the video mention higher prices. At one point, Gatter says that “we’re not in this because that the money,” and also later she reiterates the “money is not the necessary thing.”

Though few studies that costs connected with fetal organization acquisition room available, existing proof does indicate the prices named in the video clip are in heat with basic practices. The national Institutes of wellness conducts research with fetal tissue, and in the so late 1990s, the federal government Accountability Office (then well-known as the General audit Office) looked into the acquisition of such tissue, finding that the direct expense to researchers was “low.” GAO stated payments primarily went come “central tissue suppliers,” together opposed to health and wellness clinics. In many cases, GAO discovered that clinics did not charge researchers, but when they did, the expense ranged from $2 to $75. The report did not resolve how lot clinics could have received from main tissue suppliers, i beg your pardon is an ext analogous to the instance presented in the video.

What does the law Say?

In a explain made to CNN, an additional presidential candidate, retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson, dubbed the practice discussed in the video clip a “clear violation of federal law.” The “sale” that organs, both adult and fetal, because that transplantation is without doubt illegal, however donation of organization — both indigenous aborted fetuses and also from adult — is not. And also payment because that “reasonable” prices is also permitted under the law.

The video itself highlights a section of title 42 that the U.S. Code, which reads: “It shall it is in unlawful for any kind of person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any kind of human body organ for valuable consideration for usage in human being transplantation if the transfer affects federal government commerce.” The law does encompass fetal organization in that is definitions. It says that the hatchet “valuable consideration” doesn’t include “reasonable payments” because that removal, transportation, preservation and also other connected costs.

In 1993, a regulation pertaining to federally funded NIH research study was spread that enables donation the fetal tissue from induced abortions if details criteria are met. These include that the mrs donating is not conscious of the recipients of the tissue, and that the abortion timing, actions or an approach itself would not be changed for the sole objective of obtaining the tissue.

The 1993 law also says that it is unlawful “for any type of person come knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any type of human fetal tissue for an important consideration if the transfer affects federal government commerce.” The legislation again excludes the varieties of expenses Nucatola questioned in the video: “The term ‘valuable consideration’ does not incorporate reasonable payments connected with the transportation, implantation, processing, preservation, top quality control, or warehouse of human fetal tissue.”

The American medical Association echoes this in its ethical guidelines ~ above the issue: “Fetal organization is not noted in exchange because that financial remuneration above that i m sorry is crucial to covering reasonable expenses.”

Why Is Fetal organization Scientifically Useful?

Historically, the usage of fetal tissue has produced some groundbreaking scientific discoveries. Follow to the American culture for cabinet Biology, a non-profit representing a big and varied team of scientists, “Fetal cells hold distinct promise for biomedical research because of their capacity to rapidly divide, grow, and adapt to new environments. This provides fetal organization research appropriate to a wide variety of diseases and also medical conditions.”

According to the Guttmacher Institute, a nonprofit concentrated on sexual and reproductive health, tissue from fetuses has actually been used since the 1930s for a variety of purposes. Perhaps most famously, the 1954 Nobel prize in medication was forgive to researcher who controlled to grow polio vaccine in fetal kidney cabinet cultures.

In one more example, Leonard Hayflick developed a cell line from an aborted fetus in the beforehand 1960s that has actually been offered to create vaccines versus measles, rubella, shingles and also other diseases. Paul Offit, director of the Vaccine Education facility at the Children’s Hospital that Philadelphia, called the journal Nature in 2013 that “hese cells from one fetus have no doubt saved the resides of countless people.”

In an ext recent years, however, the usage of stem cells because that therapeutic and research purposes has actually taken a more main role than fetal tissue. As Arthur Caplan, a bioethicist at brand-new York University, called Buzzfeed News, “fetal cells space not a big deal in science anymore.”

In spite of the waning interest, it remains legal to donate organization from a legitimate aborted fetus, and also for that organization to be used for study purposes.

See more: Why Am I Dreaming You Have A Baby Girl ? Dreaming Of Having A Baby Girl

Editor’s Note: SciCheck is made possible by a give from the Stanton Foundation.