BOISE — an Idaho male scheduled because that execution in 3 weeks is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to avoid the state from moving forward with his lethal injection while it reviews his case.

You are watching: Does idaho have the death penalty


Attorneys because that Gerald Ross Pizzuto Jr. Filed the inquiry on Thursday, asking the nation’s highest possible court to review whether the would have been convicted if jurors had actually known about a an enig meeting in between court officials and also attorneys for a co-defendant who later testified against Pizzuto. The inquiry is most likely a long shot — the exceedingly rare for the supreme Court come agree to think about an “extraordinary writ the habeas corpus” choose the one filed in Pizzuto’s case.


Pizzuto was among three guys charged in connection with the 1985 murders of Berta and also Del Herndon. Berta Herndon, 58, and also her nephew Del, 37, to be prospecting at a far cabin near McCall as soon as prosecutors claimed they were bound, robbed and killed. Both Herndons were beaten and also Del was likewise shot.


Pizzuto, James Rice and Bill Odom were arrested in connection with the crime. The three guys were camping together nearby, and also according come court records Odom and Rice were discussing robbing some anglers when Pizzuto left and also walked towards the Herndon’s cabin, saying he was going “hunting.”


Rice and also Odom later approached the cabin and said they heard “bashing hole sounds,” before Pizzuto arised with a hammer, a rifle and revolver, money and cowboy boots. Rice go in the cabin and also found the Herndons lying on the ground through blood on your heads. Rice then shot Del Herndon, according to the court records, because his legs were shaking and also Rice “didn’t want him come suffer.”


The three later divided up the money, hidden the bodies and robbed the cabin. After remaining several days with the other two in Cascade, Rice take it a bus to California and also reported the killing to police.


Rice later reached a plea deal and testified for the prosecution, informing the jury that under the plea he would protect against the fatality penalty however expected to be sentenced to life in jail for 2 counts of 2nd degree murder. Odom additionally reached a resolve prosecutors, pleading guilty to voluntary manslaughter and also grand theft charges.


Both Rice and also Odom to be released from jail after serving around 12 and 10 years respectively. Pizzuto was sentenced to death, and it was just years later on — lengthy after his conviction to be final and also his very first appeal had actually been denied — the Pizzuto learned that prosecutors and the judge had actually promised Rice the he would just serve about 14 years in prison in exchange because that his testimony.


Pizzuto’s attorneys complete that if the jury had actually known Rice had actually a secret deal v the judge and also prosecutors and lied ~ above the angry stand about it, the Pizzuto might not have actually been sentenced to death.


Pizzuto’s attorneys make the same dispute to the ninth U.S. Circuit Court number of years ago, however lost the case in 2012. In the ruling, a three-judge appellate panel stated the evidence of the mystery meeting and also false testimony was troubling, but that over there were enough aggravating determinants to Pizzuto’s crime to justify the death penalty anyway. Among the judges dissented, however, speak the an enig deal and false testimony would likely have thrown the credibility of the entire trial in doubt if jurors had known, potentially bring about a various outcome.


The court documents in Pizzuto’s instance are tangled. At one point, the Idaho can be fried Court erroneously wrote in a judgment that Pizzuto, not Rice, had actually shot Del Herndon. The court later acknowledged the error but never approve a officially correction, causing it to be repeated in short articles by The linked Press and also other news outlets end the years.


Pizzuto, now 65, has actually terminal bladder cancer and heart an illness and is most likely near the end of his organic life. His attorneys have additionally asked the state’s pardons commission to grant him clemency and also let him die naturally rather than spending taxpayer dollars on his execution. Pizzuto is scheduled to die by lethal injection top top June 2.

See more: Do Type Two Diabetics Take Insulin And Type 2 Diabetes, Type 2 Diabetes And Insulin


Keith Eugene Wells was executed in 1994, Paul Ezra Rhoades to be executed in 2011 and also Richard Albert Leavitt to be executed in 2012.


*