Mask mandates space one policy tool state governments have provided to tackle the recurring COVID-19 pandemic. But does the enforcement of this mandates adjust the method Americans think around them? In brand-new research, Luke Fowler and Jeff Lyons examine the effects of mask mandate enforcement measures, such as fines, ~ above public assistance in Idaho. They discover that Democrats room overwhelmingly supportive nevertheless of enforcement, yet Republican support drops significantly, successfully robbing state Republican leader of a way to obtrude mask mandates in Idaho.

You are watching: Does idaho have a mask mandate


Most united state states have issued some form of a mask mandate requiring face coverings since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic in march 2020. Specific provisions vary across states. Enforcement has actually been lax through police encouraging compliance, however hesitating to worry fines or do arrests. Of course, traditional enforcement the mask mandates is much more effective than voluntary compliance, and voluntary mandates are regarded as unfair and also contribute to the stigmatization that mask wearing. However, there is additionally the concern of regulate aversion, where people are less likely to comply with mandated behaviors due to the fact that freedom of selection has been removed and/or a absence of to trust in government.

Idaho is among the couple of states to withstand a state-wide mask mandate, back it to be a main debate during November and also December 2020 as soon as COVID-19 instances were rapidly rising. Because local federal governments and regional health districts in Idaho have wide authority to take on public wellness ordinances, more than a dozen implemented mask mandates. In response, the state residence passed regulation banning local mask mandates, but the bill died in Senate committee. Follow to Republican governor Brad Little: “ mandate is problematic if the community doesn’t believe in it and we room a local control state.” Unsurprisingly, several groups associated opposed come mask mandates organized protests and also demonstrations, including a mask burning event in former of the State Capitol.

This sets up a difficult an obstacle for policy architecture in locations like Idaho whereby citizens space unlikely to comply v a mask mandate if that is no enforced however enforcement may produce too much opposition because that a mask mandate come be adopted and risk additional polarization approximately a contentious issue. Thus, state leaders space then challenged with picking their poison.

Split Sample Survey

We examine this concern further with data indigenous a survey carried out by Boise State college that accumulated a geographically and demographically representative sample that 1,000 respondents from Idaho in between November 29 and December 3, 2020. We usage a break-up sample inspection research architecture to test how including enforcement provisions (specifically, a fine) affects support for a mask mandate.

The baseline inquiry asked: “Would you assistance or oppose the state making it mandatory to wear masks in public locations to hit the coronavirus pandemic?” (57.9 percent the respondents either strongly or somewhat support a mask mandate, when 40.5 percent strong or somewhat oppose a mandate). Ours enforcement question asked: “Would you support or oppose the state making the mandatory come wear masks in public places to hit the coronavirus pandemic, where no wearing a mask can be punishable by a fine?” (51.2 percent one of two people strongly or somewhat support, while 46.4 percent one of two people strongly or somewhat oppose).

Figure 1 charts the interaction in between enforcement and also partisanship. Top top one hand, solid Democrats are supportive the mask mandates, nevertheless of whether over there is an enforcement supplication or not. ~ above the various other hand, lacking an enforcement provision, the probability that Republicans strongly opposing mask mandates is .52, yet it rises to .71 when an enforcement supplication is included, when the probability of strongly sustaining mask mandates is .23 once there is no enforcement language and also falls come .11 when an enforcement treatment is included. In sum, Democrats are overwhelmingly supportive nevertheless of enforcement, but Republican the opposite increases and support drops by coherent quantities in the existence of enforcement provisions.

Figure 1 – guess Probability of strong Support and strong Opposition for Mask Mandates


This retrenchment in assistance is consequential in the without the fine, support is around 58 percent, however with the fine, that drops to 51 percent. Provided a sampling error that +/- 3.1 percent, this method that without the fine, a clear bulk supports a mask mandate, however with a fine, a majority may or may not support it. This is almost entirely caused by eroding Republican support, a vital constituency in Idaho.

Policy & political Implications

This finding climate creates a difficult difficulty for state leaders trying to architecture policies the induce compliance with public health and wellness recommendations. While traditional logic says that the most efficient strategy because that containing COVID-19 is classic enforcement that a mask mandate, including levying fines, doing for this reason may cause polarized attitudes and also retrenchment in support among a crucial constituency that is both crucial to administer coalitions and whose compliance will be critical for virus containment.


Photo by Adam Nieścioruk top top Unsplash

Furthermore, this would likewise likely stir added political demonstrations amongst an outspoken contingent, an overwhelming Republican leader from in ~ their very own party. Together Democrats are frequently uncompetitive in state-wide elections in Idaho, the most ardent difficulties are most likely to come indigenous the right, i beg your pardon Governor tiny has currently experienced native his own Lieutenant Governor, bring about tension inside Idaho’s Republican Party. Thus, the political risks of adopting a mask mandate room high for Republicans trying come stave off dispute within their own party.

But, with no clean enforcement mechanism, adopting a mandate may not lead to much more mask wearing, throughout a time when it is one of the most important actions to reduce ar spread. While this strategy may cause less political tension, it certainly would not eliminate it, as a sizable minority would still protest a mandate in any form. Importantly, the sizable minority becomes outsized within the narrow confines of the Republican Party, carrying more weight for a Republican governor hoping to maintain his political clout.

Given this situation, Idaho state leaders, namely governor Little, decided a third option and pushed a rigid of personal responsibility in hopes that citizens might be nudged into adhering to public wellness recommendations there is no a officially policy. This is largely akin come a publicly outreach or education projects aimed at an altering perceptions that a desired behavior, as an alternative policy tool to mandates. Come a particular extent, this appears to it is in a compromise between formal and enforced plans to save COVID promoted by democratic leaders and also questioning the efficacy of masks all together as part Republican chosen officials have actually done. The general public health and also political results of this decision stay to it is in seen, but this evaluation certainly illustrates why creating policies for COVID-19 is difficult in conservative states.

Please review our comments policy prior to commenting.

Note: This post gives the views of the author, and not the place of USAPP – American Politics and also Policy, nor the London institution of Economics. 

Shortened URL for this post:

About the authors

Luke Fowler – Boise State UniversityLuke Fowler is an combine professor and also facutly director at Boise StateUniversity’s school of public Service. His study interests include state and also local politics, intergovernmental relations, eco-friendly policy, and policy implementation.

See more:
Did Trump Wear A Mask In Michigan Ford Factory Without Wearing Mask

Jeff Lyons – Boise State UniversityJeff Lyons is an associate professor of political science and also the political science program lead in ~ Boise State University’s institution of public Service. His research focuses on American windy opinion and also political behavior.