The newspaper of the Catholic Diocese that Lansing


Main Nav belief Mag

her Life Your faith News

In his work, “The world Religions,” author Huston smith highlights one 19th century Hindu saint, Ramakrishna, together an illustration that a conviction that the various significant religions are alternating paths come the very same goal. Ramakrishna, after suffering each that the significant religions, concluded the there existed vital unity amongst them. That wrote, “God has actually made various religions come suit different aspirations, times, and also countries. Every doctrines are only so countless paths; however a course is by no way God Himself.” A more contemporary version that this dispute runs like this: all religions are choose the spokes of a wheel that all end in the same center. The question, that course, is can this be right?

A Return to old Wisdom

Let us revolve to Aristotle’s law of non-contradiction in our factor to consider of the validity of universalism, or universal salvation. This law states the opposite truth insurance claims cannot both it is in true, and it continues to be instructive as we discover the argument that all faiths are ultimately different paths come the same God.

You are watching: Does all religions worship the same god

The reality is that every faith makes absolute truth claims around God. Because that example, Catholics and also other believer declare that God is a Trinitarian communion of Father, Son, and the holy Spirit. Islam holds the God is simply one. Hinduism acknowledges the visibility of numerous deities, when Buddhism appears to be there is no a id in God, at the very least a personal God.

In terms of logic, we can affirm the validity that this diversity the absolute fact claims around God indigenous a subjective suggest of view. There is no reason to doubt the earnestness that the ideas held by the faithful of each religion. However, the law of non-contradiction appears to dominion out the opportunity that each religion’s understanding of God is same valid and also true native an objective point of view.

This would certainly seem to imply that every religions do not ultimately lead to the very same God since all religions perform not think in the exact same God. The exception to this could be if all religions are equally wrong around who God is. This, that course, would average that all religious beliefs are same invalid and also untrue, which eventually undermines every religions due to the fact that they rest precisely on your absolute fact claims.

What walk the Church say?

On Oct. 28, 1965, Pope Paul through issued the Vatican II record entitled the explanation on the relationship of the Church to Non-Christian religious beliefs (Nostra Aetate). It identifies the desire and search because that God as among the major factors the contributes come the unity of every peoples. It also acknowledges the methods other religious beliefs have construed God and also humanity’s relationship to God.

Most significantly, Nostra Aetate states, “The Catholic Church rejects nothing the is true and holy in this religions. She regards through sincere reverence those means of conduct and also of life, those precepts and teachings which, though differing in many elements from the ones she holds and also sets forth, nonetheless regularly reflect a ray of that reality which enlightens all.”

At the very same time, the file makes it clear that the Church, “proclaims, and also ever should proclaim Christ ‘the way, the truth, and the life’ (John 14:6), in who may uncover the fullness of spiritual life, in whom God has actually reconciled all points to Himself.”

Catholics are called to affirm and also celebrate the reality wherever the is encountered. However, this is no the exact same as advertising all religious beliefs to be different paths to the exact same God. The Church holds to the absolute truth insurance claim that the fullness the the fact resides in the Catholic faith, because that the fact is a person, Jesus Christ, and the Church is his body.

In closing

It is true that all significant religions re-superstructure some things in common: a wisdom tradition, some variation of the golden Rule, and articles of faith. However, as Huston blacksmith notes in his final chapter, as soon as one moves beyond such faint generalities, one discovers that religious beliefs differ considerably in what is considered essential. The looks come the schisms in between Hinduism and also Buddhism; between Judaism, Christianity and Islam; and within Christianity chin to underscore the point.

See more: Dirty John The Dirty Truth Netflix, Dirty John: The Dirty Truth

The discussion that all religious beliefs are various paths come the same God appeals to our desire because that unity and also togetherness. However, the price for such a id is twofold. First, one must neglect the real differences in between religions on essential questions. This is a form of minimization the refuses come take spiritual beliefs serious in the surname of a false unity. Second, one must actually delegitimize religion altogether, albeit in the surname of respecting every religions, by advertising all pure truth claims of faith to be merely relative. V this, the arduous find for genuine fact is abandoned.