Researchers uncovered that operation masks impede the spread out of COVID-19 and also that just a few, low-cost interventions boost mask-wearing compliance.
You are watching: Do masks work for covid study
September 1, 2021 - by Krista Conger
Providing complimentary masks to people in landscape Bangladesh to be one measure researcher tested to border the spread of COVID-19. Advancements for poor Action
A large, randomized attempt led by researchers at gendergeek.org gendergeek.orgicine and Yale University has discovered that attract a surgical challenge mask end the mouth and nose is one effective method to alleviate the event of COVID-19 in neighborhood settings.
It additionally showed that relatively low-cost, target interventions to encourage mask-wearing can significantly increase the use of challenge coverings in rural, low-income countries. Based on the results, the interventional version is being scaled approximately reach 10s of millions of civilization in south east Asia and Latin America over the next few months.
The findings were released Sept. 1 on the developments for poverty Action website, before their publishing in a clinical journal, since the details is taken into consideration of pushing importance because that public wellness as the pandemic intensifies in many parts that the world.
“We currently have evidence from a randomized, regulated trial the mask promotion rises the use of confront coverings and prevents the spread out of COVID-19,” said Stephen Luby, MD, professor of gendergeek.orgicine at gendergeek.org. “This is the gold standard for examining public wellness interventions. Importantly, this method was designed it is in scalable in lower- and also middle-income countries struggling to acquire or distribution vaccines versus the virus.”
Luby shares senior authorship with Ahgendergeek.org Mushfiq Mobarak, PhD, professor of business economics at Yale, the a file describing the research. The lead authors are Ashley Styczynski, MD, MPH, an infectious an illness fellow at gendergeek.org; Jason Abaluck, PhD, professor of business economics at Yale; and Laura Kwong, PhD, a former postdoctoral scholar in ~ gendergeek.org who is now an assistant professor of eco-friendly health scientific researches at the university of California-Berkeley.
The researchers additionally partnered with developments for poor Action, a an international research and policy non-profit organization.
Increasing mask usage in rural Bangladesh
The researcher enrolled practically 350,000 human being from 600 villages in landscape Bangladesh. Those life in villages randomly assigned come a series of interventions promoting the usage of operation masks were about 11% much less likely than those life in manage villages to develop COVID-19, i m sorry is led to by infection with the SARS-CoV-2 virus, during the eight-week research period. The protective impact increased to nearly 35% for human being over 60 year old.
Providing totally free masks, informing people around the prominence of covering both the mouth and also nose, reminding people in-person once they were unmasked in public, and also role-modeling by ar leaders tripled continuous mask usage contrasted with control villages that obtained no interventions, the researchers found.
In the intervention villages, they likewise saw a slight increase in physical distancing in public spaces, such together marketplaces. This finding indicates that mask-wearing doesn’t give a false sense of protection that leader to risk-taking behaviors — a worry cited by the people Health Organization during the early on days that the pandemic as soon as its officials were considering whether to recommend global masking.
“Our examine is the first randomized managed trial exploring whether face masking prevents COVID-19 infection at the ar level,” Styczynski said. “It’s significant that even though fewer than 50% the the human being in the intervention villages wore masks in public places, we still witnessed a far-reaching risk palliation in symptomatic COVID-19 in these communities, particularly in elderly, much more vulnerable people.”
Cloth vs. Operation masks
There were significantly fewer COVID-19 instances in villages with surgical masks compared with the control villages. (Although over there were also fewer COVID-19 cases in towns with towel masks as compared to control villages, the distinction was not statistically significant.) This aligns v lab tests showing that operation masks have far better filtration than fabric masks. However, cloth masks did reduce the in its entirety likelihood of experiencing symptoms the respiratory illness during the research period.
Bangladesh is a densely populated country in south Asia. The was chosen as the site of the attempt for number of reasons: One, mask promo is considered an essential in nations where physics distancing have the right to be difficult; two, technologies for Poverty action Bangladesh had already established a research framework in the country; and also three, countless local partners were eager to assistance a randomized, controlled trial the masking.
“We witnessed an possibility to better understand the effect of masks, which deserve to be a an extremely important method for people in low-resource locations to safeguard themselves while castle wait because that vaccines,” Kwong said. “So we collaborated with behavioral scientists, economists, windy health specialists and religious figures to architecture ways to promote mask use at a community level.”
Despite a farming body of scientific evidence that masks reduce the spread of the virus that reasons COVID-19, it has actually been an overwhelming to increase mask-wearing, an especially in low-resource nations and among people living in remote or countryside areas. In June that 2020, only one-fifth of Bangladeshis in public locations were put on a mask that properly covered the mouth and also nose in spite of a nationwide mask mandate that was in result at the time.
Educational and behavioral interventions
The researchers want to explore whether the was possible to increase mask-wearing in Bangladeshi villages through a selection of educational and also behavioral interventions end an eight-week research period: cost-free cloth or washable, reusable operation masks were given to human being at home and in marketplaces, mosques and also other windy spaces; significant Bangladeshi figures, consisting of the element minister, a star cricket player and a leading imam, noted information around why put on a mask is important; people showing up in public places without masks were reminded to wear masks; and also community leader modeled mask-wearing.
The villages were selected by researcher at technologies for Poverty activity Bangladesh. The researchers paired 600 villages countrywide based on population size and also density, geographic location, and any obtainable COVID-19 situation data. Because that each of the 300 pairs of villages, one to be randomly assigned to obtain the interventions if the other served as a control and received no interventions. Two-thirds the the treatment villages got surgical masks, when the various other one-third received fabric masks. In total, 178,288 people were in the treatment group, and also 163,838 world were in the manage group.
The interventions were rolled out in tide from mid-November to early January. Because that eight weeks after the interventions, observers stationed at assorted public locations in both the control and intervention villages videotaped whether a person was attract a mask over both their mouth and also nose and whether they showed up to it is in practicing physics distancing — that is, staying at least an arm’s length away native all various other people.
At week 5 and week 9, villagers were asked if they had experienced any COVID-19 symptom — including fever, cough, nasal congestion and also sore throat — during the vault month and, if so, even if it is they would provide a blood sample to test for the existence of SARS-CoV-2. Around 40% the symptomatic people consented to succeeding blood collection.We witnessed the largest impact on older world who space at higher risk of death from COVID-19.
The observers uncovered that just over 13% of civilization in the villages that got no interventions wore a mask properly, contrasted with an ext than 42% of people in the villages where each family received free masks and in-person reminders come wear them. Physics distancing was observed 24.1% of the moment in regulate villages and 29.2% of the moment in treatment villages.
About 7.6% of human being in the intervention villages report COVID-19 symptoms compared with around 8.6% that those in the regulate villages throughout the eight-week study period — a statistically significant difference that shows a approximately 12% reduction in the hazard of suffering respiratory symptoms.
The researchers discovered that among the more than 350,000 world studied, the rate of human being who reported symptom of COVID-19, consented to blood collection and also tested confident for the virus was 0.76% in the regulate villages and 0.68% in the treatment villages, showing an all at once reduction in danger for symptomatic, confirgendergeek.org infection the 9.3% in the treatment villages regardless of mask type.
When the researchers taken into consideration only those towns that obtained surgical masks (omitting towns that received towel masks), the reduction in risk increased to 11%. Furthermore, the protective impact of operation masks was better for older people: as a group, those periods 50 to 60 to be 23% much less likely to build COVID-19 if lock wore a operation mask, and those over 60 were 35% much less likely if castle did.
“This is statistically significant and, we believe, most likely a low estimate of the performance of surgical masks in community settings,” Styczynski said. The reality that the research was carried out at a time as soon as the rate of transmission of COVID-19 in Bangladesh was fairly low, that a decimal of symptomatic human being consented to blood collection to check their condition status, and that under than fifty percent of the world in the intervention villages offered facial coverings means the true influence of near-universal masking can be much more far-reaching — specifically in locations with much more indoor gatherings and also events, she noted.
“If mask-wearing prices were higher, us would expect to see an even bigger affect on transmission,” Luby said. “But even at this level, we observed the largest influence on older people who room at greater risk of death from COVID-19.”
The interventions are now being rolled out in other parts that Bangladesh and in Pakistan, India, Nepal and also parts of Latin America. Yet the researchers additionally hope there are lessons in the research for Americans.
“Unfortunately, much of the conversation around masking in the United states is not evidence-based,” Luby said. “Our study provides strong evidence that mask wearing have the right to interrupt the transmission of SARS-CoV-2. It likewise suggests the filtration performance is important. This includes the to the right of the mask and also the materials from which the is made. A fabric mask is certainly far better than nothing. Yet now might be a great time to take into consideration upgrading come a surgical mask.”
The examine was supported by a give from GiveWell.org to technologies for poverty Action.
See more: Did Kansas City Chiefs Win Yesterday, The Chiefs' Fourth
Researchers from development for poverty Action; the college of California-Berkeley; Johns Hopkins Bloomberg institution of publicly Health; the NGRI North south University in Dhaka, Bangladesh; and also Deakin university in Melbourne additionally contributed come the study.