They’re contributing billions the dollars a year to social Security, but may never ever reap any type of retirement benefits from it.

You are watching: Do illegal immigrants pay into social security


Every year, the society Security administration collects billions the dollars in taxes the it doesn’t understand who paid. Whenever job send in W-2 forms with Social defense numbers that don’t complement anyone ~ above record, the company routes the paperwork to what’s dubbed the income Suspense File, wherein it sits until people can prove the earnings were theirs, allowing them to one day collect retirement benefits.

The revenue Suspense file now contains Social defense tax creates that date back to 1937 and also are linked to the taxes the were payment on almost $1.3 sunshine in wages. Few of the W-2s in that belong to world who gained married and never reported transforming their name. Others are world who filled the end their tax forms incorrectly. As of 2014, initiatives to track down these taxpayers enabled the social Security management to complement 171 million tax creates to your rightful owners.

But there space still around 340 million unclaimed tax develops recorded in the file, contrasted with 270 million virtually a te ago. A great portion of those creates were filed by employers on instead of of several of the most unlikely funders of social Security: undocumented immigrants. In fact, illegal immigrant is taken into consideration largely responsible for the mushrooming the the file, v undocumented workers paying billions in taxes for retirement services they will likely never receive.

It works choose this: numerous immigrants that aren’t authorized to work in the United says buy fake Social security cards and present castle to your employers, that either don’t know they room fake or don’t look too closely. Once the employer submits a W-2 form and a taxes payment on those workers’ instead of to the Social defense Administration, the federal government holds ~ above those payroll taxes, also if the Social protection number isn’t attached to anyone on file. And also then, a huge chunk of the money end up in the Social protection trust funds, native which retirement benefits room doled the end to aging Americans.

The Social security system has actually grown progressively reliant top top this present of revenue, an especially as aging baby Boomers start to retire. Stephen Goss, the chef actuary that the Social security Administration, approximates that around 1.8 million immigrant were working with fake or steal Social protection cards in 2010, and also he expects the number to with 3.4 million through 2040. He calculates that undocumented immigrants paid $13 billion into the retirement trust money that year, and also only got about $1 exchange rate in benefits. “We calculation that earnings by unauthorized immigrants result in a network positive impact on Social protection financial standing generally, and also that this result contributed approximately $12 exchange rate to the cash flow of the routine for 2010,” gun concluded in a 2013 evaluation of the affect of undocumented immigrants on social Security.

Ironically, a item of legislation aimed in ~ curbing the rental of undocumented immigrants produced this steady resource of revenue for the Social security system. In 1986, the immigration Reform and Control Act collection penalties because that employers who knowingly rental undocumented immigrants. It to be the an initial time the federal federal government had made it a crime to employ undocumented workers. Yet instead of destroying the underground job market, this new law simply made it much more sophisticated, producing a flourishing market because that fake U.S. Birth certificates, IDs, and also Social security cards, i beg your pardon undocumented workers presented to their employers once asked for your papers. Undocumented workers began filling the end W-2 forms, and the commonwealth government began receiving and holding top top payroll taxes, even though the fake Social defense numbers didn’t complement anyone in the system. The society Security management sends no-match letters to employers to alert lock of the problem and also urge them to resolve it.

As rhetoric about illegal immigrant dominates this election cycle, it’s tough to argue the undocumented immigrants drainpipe the system. No all undocumented workers pay federal income and also Social protection taxes; numerous are still payment in cash and also never fill out W-2 forms, therefore how many of castle independently record tax returns as self-employed contractors is unclear. The institute on Taxation and also Economic Policy, a Washington, D.C., think tank, estimates that about half of undocumented employees in the United states pay revenue taxes. Castle also assist fund publicly schools and local government services by paying sales and property count like any type of other resident. This included up to around $10.6 billion in state and also local count in 2010, according to an evaluation by the institute.

And in the past 20 years, the internal Revenue business has make it simpler for workers to pay taxes if they don’t have actually a Social defense number (or a fake one, for that matter). Workers who are paid illegally in cash can still pay your taxes v an Individual taxes Identification Number (ITIN), filing a return simply like any kind of other taxpayer; having a background of paying taxes have the right to be critical step in securing legit status. In 2010, about 3 million civilization paid more than $870 million in income taxes using an ITIN, and according come the IRS, ITIN filers salary $9 billion in payroll counting annually. (The IRS says it does not share ITIN details with immigration authorities.)

Tanya Gonzalez, the executive director the the nonprofit spiritual Heart center in Richmond, Virginia, organized the an initial federally-funded, bilingual tax-assistance regime in the region, which sits in one of the two claims that have actually seen increases in the variety of undocumented immigrants due to the fact that the recession. She maintained hearing the undocumented immigrant in the Richmond area were acquiring ripped turn off by taxes preparers, and also a friend at the IRS told her around the commonwealth grants offered to open free tax-assistance centers in low-income areas.

At spiritual Heart’s tax-assistance site, she has actually helped numerous immigrants use for a taxpayer identification number, which allows them to paper their taxes as contractors. The usage of ITIN has actually grown popular amongst immigrant workers in Richmond, she says, as countless await comprehensive immigration reform. Past legalization efforts have forced undocumented immigrants to prove exactly how long they’ve been living in the unified States, and to salary the taxes castle owe before receiving legal status. “They desire to display that they’ve to be paying taxes and also have their files in bespeak as lot as they can,” states Gonzalez, including that some world are on payment plans, while others merely can’t purchased to salary taxes in ~ all.

See more: How Much Do Guests On News Shows Get Paid On Talk Shows? Do People Get Paid To Appear On Cnn,Msnbc, Etc

One undocumented worker from central Mexico that gets aid with his count at spiritual Heart called me the he started paying taxes 4 years ago, after learning that it could one day aid him stay in the unified States. (He asked no to be named because of his legitimate status.) A 31-year-old see worker, he moved to Richmond in 1999 and also now renders up come $1,700 a month maintaining golf courses seven days a week. Employees at sacred Heart told him that if the filed taxes v an ITIN, that could aid him gain legal status in the United states if congress passes considerable immigration reform. Together those efforts remain stalled in Washington, D.C., his wages room recorded right into the earnings Suspense File, and his taxes enter the Social defense trust funds. “So many human being say us are here burdening the country, however we are paying their retirements,” he told me. Because that now, he doesn’t mind supporting the Social defense system, he says, but hopes someday he deserve to reap the benefits, too.