This choice is both around who we want the chairman to be, and also what type of ar we really desire America come be.

You are watching: Did obama put kids in cages?


Biden says migrant household separation 'violates every concept of who we are as a nation'

Oct. 23, 202002:29
This is what the 2020 presidential choice comes under to: perform you want a bully in the White house or not?

The seminal minute that solidified this as the significance of the race came on Thursday night throughout the 2nd debate between President Donald Trump and former Vice president Joe Biden, and also was revealed as component of one expected collection of questions on immigration.

In response to revelations the the Trump management had yet to reunify 545 migrant youngsters with your parents nearly two years after a “zero tolerance” police caused the intended separation that thousands of children who had actually crossed the border v their parental or guardians — a practice some labeled together torture — Biden emotionally labeling the practice of household separations "criminal."


OpinionRep. Jackie Speier: dog in kennels are treated much better than the migrants I witnessed detained in Texas

"Their children were ripped from their arms and separated," Biden said, in response to factually not correct assertions by Trump the they were unaccompanied minors smuggled right into the United states by coyotes rather than family members members. "And currently they cannot uncover over 500 sets of those parents and also those children are alone — i do not have anything to go, i do not have anything to go."

The quantity of empathy Trump presented in response was zero. "They space so well taken treatment of," that said. "They’re in facilities that were so clean, the have obtained such an excellent ..." (at which point he to be interrupted).

Unlike anything trump card has ever done, Biden admitted the what taken place under chairman Barack Obama to be a mistake.

He also, in the food of the exchange, admitted the the children were being organized in cages, but blamed the Obama administration: "Who built the cages, Joe?," the demanded. "Who constructed the cages, Joe?"

Trump was factually correct in recall Biden that cages were part of one embarrassing Obama management get-tough policy in 2014 that likewise dehumanized migrants as part of a massive detention policy, however it is just under Trump that the United says systematically separated youngsters from their family members with no plans because that reunification. Trump card was additionally correct to imply that the Obama management laid the foundation for trump to properly implement tougher immigration policies.

Yet unequal anything trump card has ever done, Biden admitted come a nationwide television audience that what happened under president Barack Obama was a failure — and also it was actually the very first thing the said as soon as asked around the Obama"s administration"s culpability for the existing situation. “Because us made a mistake," the told the moderator Kristen Welker. "It took too long to acquire it right."

And, when he was done admitting that there to be a difficulty with what the Obama administration had done, Biden climate rattled off all that he would do to best a wrong. Because that the countless immigrant rights supporters who had been demanding adjust from very first Obama and also then trumped on this issues, it is clean that, if Trump is a shed cause, Biden is still qualified of growth.

Trump, though, just stuck come his guns, continuously asserting that there is naught wrong v either his immigration policies or exactly how they to be implemented. He refused to expropriate that he has any kind of reason for any type of remorse — though, minutes later, the did proudly proclaim that he to be the the very least racist human in the room.

Americans room truly going to it is in deciding in the next 11 job what kind of president and also what kind of country we want to have actually in 2021.

But the f----your-feelings mantra the all but defined his project in 2016 and also much that his presidency due to the fact that rings hole in 2020, between a an international pandemic that deserve to only be mitigated through showing treatment for others (by attract a mask, i m sorry the president additionally often refuses to do).

Tossing the end neo-nativist immigration talking points grounded in no factual truth (cartels! coyotes! gangs!) in response to questions around the 545 children his administration deliberately traumatized and effectively orphaned as punishment for their parents" make the efforts to cross the border to escape violence and poverty to be one an ext example the a president who developed a politics career off of demonizing migrants simply doubling down. Any kind of acknowledgment of his culpability for among the country’s most horrific ethical stains to be not and also will not occur — as with how that shirks duty for his administration"s failures throughout the Covid-19 crisis.


It"s hard not to watch him for that he is now: the guy who speak tough however who can"t accept any responsibility because that the after-effects for one of two people his hard talk or his actions. And also those suburban white women that gravitated to that claimed toughness together a 2016 big middle finger to the so-called liberal establishment are currently reconsidering the after-effects of that choice. They could not have been screaming about Obama"s pro-deportation plan six year ago, but they can see quite plainly now what fear that can lead to once passed turn off to someone favor Trump. His brand of "immigration reform" is a country that cages babies choose dogs in freeze cold warehouses and also celebrates the the cages room clean; we all know now it"s time for something new.

But the exchange around immigration in between Biden and also Trump likewise revealed a depths truth about what Americans space truly going to be deciding in the following 11 days: What type of president and also what type of country do we want to have actually in 2021?


Do we want the devilish bully, the fake tough-guy who isn"t so difficult when asked come take duty for his actions? Or perform we want the male who is horrified by youngsters in cages, and willing to recognize that what duty he play in the ultimate, devastating outcome was wrong and also he"s learned he needs to do better?

From the look at of the polls, the price is that more and much more people desire the latter, no the former. (The challenging guy persona is still working well through white suburban men, however not v white suburban women.)

Trump continues to it is in a bully from his bully pulpit because it provided him a success in 2016 — however 2020 might be different. His brand that gratuitous nastiness has lost the appeal; unfortunately, it take it thousands of kids traumatized by his cruelty, nearly 225,000 American dead therefore far, millions sickened, millions much more unemployed and also unfathomable economic and personal losses for everyone for the to happen.

See more: Earth Is Closest To The Sun At A Point Called, Perihelion And Aphelion 2021 / 2022

Julio Ricardo Varela
Julio Ricardo Varela is the co-host the the Webby-nominated In The thick podcast and founder the, now component of Futuro Media.