Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the fact so you have the right to be an informed participant in democracy.We require your help.
You are watching: Did obama ever pass a budget
In a speech the looked beyond the major to the general election, Mitt Romney, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, hit chairman Barack Obama over his taking care of of the recession."President Obama"s answer come our economic situation was more spending, much more debt and also larger government. And by the end of his term in office he will have added nearly as much public debt together all the former presidents combined," Romney claimed in an April 4, 2012, speech to newspaper editors. "No chairman has ever run a trillion-dollar deficit. The brand-new normal the president would have us embrace is trillion-dollar deficits and 8 percent unemployment. Through all of this, president Obama has actually failed to also pass a budget."There are a the majority of accusations pack in there, however that critical one -- that Obama failed to pass a spending plan -- piqued our interest most.How the budget plan happensThe federal budget plan doesn’t gain enacted the means other regulations do. The procedure starts through the chairman submitting his spending plan request to Congress early on in the year. The voluminous document is partially a presidential wish list, but it additionally gives conference a framework."The ‘PresBud,’ together it is called, forms the communication of the fiscal year spending plan that start the complying with October," follow to this write-up from the nonpartisan Taxpayers for typical Sense.In Congress, the House and Senate have spending plan committees tasked with producing concurrent budget resolutions, using the president’s spending plan as a guide. Together Taxpayers for usual Sense wrote, "The law they breeze is because that Congressional use only: the doesn"t go to the President, it isn"t law, it simply helps Congress store its budgetary ducks in a row."So over there is the very first problem v Romney’s statement. The president doesn’t "pass" a budget. That’s Congress’ job.In Obama’s case, he has actually submitted his spending plan request annually he has been in office.Voting ~ above his requestsRomney stated in his speech the "In February, (Obama) placed forward a proposal that contained the largest tax increase in background and quiet left our national debt spiraling out of control, and also the residence rejected the unanimously."He’s right about the rejection. ~ Obama submitted his budget year 2013 budget plan proposal top top Feb. 13, 2012, house Republicans put it up because that a floor vote.The result: 414-0 against.The exact same thing happened a year earlier in the Senate. That vote: 97-0 against. Democrats didn’t support the arrangement because it has actually been supplanted by another deficit-reduction arrangement Obama had actually later outlined. Republican leader demanded a vote on Obama’s budget to present that Democrats don’t support any kind of detailed spending plan blueprint, follow to The Hill.Such votes room taken "just together a way of awkward the president and also his party," stated Patrick luigi Knudsen, a senior fellow v the conservative legacy Foundation."Usually it’s lugged up through the the contrary party because they typically anticipate that a president’s budget won’t get an extremely much support specifically if it has actually controversial facets to it," the said.Other experts agree. Stated Steve Ellis, of Taxpayers for usual Sense: "That to be pure political theater and was done to score rhetorical points."And Norman Ornstein, a scholar v the conservative American enterprise Institute, said, "it doesn’t mean a damn thing. It’s just a symbolic gesture."These votes are also what Romney’s project cited once we asked because that documentation that his statement."Everyone understands the the president has actually a unique and also important duty in facilitating that process," claimed spokesman Ryan Williams in one email. "President Obama has been an unmatched failure in that respect. His FY 2012 budget plan went under 97-0 in the Senate and his FY 2013 budget went down 414-0 in the House."Speaking the precedentWe wondered what various other budgetary scenarios have actually played out recently.Knudsen pointed to 2009, once Democrats still organized a majority in the House. They introduced a resolution that consisted of the device for the health treatment legislation championed by Obama in his budget. The resolution had many aspects of the president’s budget, Knudsen said, despite it wasn’t strictly speaking that document.Ornstein referred us to the gridlock the 2011 the resulted indigenous the debate over elevating the blame ceiling. The budget plan control act, which was passed to prevent a default on our debt and also signed by Obama no a traditional budget plan resolution, Ornstein said. However he noted: "That was actually a budget adopted by a president."Ornstein also detailed that during George W. Bush’s presidency, there were years the Democrats in congress failed to happen joint resolutions."To imply that was bush not happen a spending plan would it is in a misstatement," Ornstein said. He called Romney’s lab on Obama "at best a gun exaggeration."But in Knudsen’s view, Romney’s statement to be "technically accurate.""The president’s budgets have been carried to the floor twice and they have actually failed," Knudsen said. "It’s no atypical that that must happen, but nevertheless the branch is correct."gendergeek.org has actually examined similar accusations about a lack of budgeting as soon as they’ve to be leveled in ~ Congress. In January 2012, Republican residence member Paul Ryan charged that Senate democracy "have gone without any kind of budget at all" for an ext than 1,000 days. gendergeek.org Wisconsin rated that largely True, finding he was slightly off around the variety of days however correct that the Democrat-controlled Senate had actually gone a long time v passing a budget plan resolution.Former Louisiana Congressman and Gov. Buddy Roemer earn a fifty percent True from us once he stated in July 2011 that "Obama has actually never submitted a budget, and Congress has operated for two years there is no passing one." He to be right around Congress yet wrong about Obama.
See more: Domestic Violence Caught On Tape Warning Graphic, Independence Police Department
Our rulingIn his speech, Romney faulted Obama for failing to happen a budget. He to be correct the the two times conference voted on the president’s budget requests, both times they to be voted down. But the job of happen a budget plan resolution is no the president’s. The responsibility drops to Congress, and also even then the president doesn’t sign it. Together Ellis, our expert, put it: "The president has actually no function in passing a budget. The president have the right to cajole Congress about passing a budget and advocate because that positions and also funding levels, but in the end, congress approves the spending plan resolution for their own purposes." that’s the difference in between this and other claims we’ve rated which blamed Congress because that inaction ~ above the budget.Romney’s statement includes a grain of truth, in that two of Obama’s budget requests failed come pass. Yet citing those votes leaves a dorn impression -- namely the the votes to be anything more than political theater. Romney omitted the more critical information that passing a federal spending plan is the task of Congress. Given all that, we rate his statement greatly False.