Twitter icon A stylized bird v an open up mouth, tweeting. Twitter LinkedIn icon The native "in". LinkedIn Fliboard symbol A stylized letter F. Flipboard attach icon an image of a chain link. The symobilizes a website connect url. Copy attach
*

Republican presidential nominee Trump at a campaign event in ~ the Trump global Hotel in Washington. Thomson Reuters DES MOINES, Iowa — When lastly coming roughly to the fact President Barack Obama to be born in the US, Donald trump tacked ~ above a destruction at his White house rival. It to be Hillary Clinton, that said, who started the rumor that Obama to be born abroad."President Barack Obama to be born in the joined States. Period," the Republican presidential nominee claimed last week, prior to quickly deflecting blame. "Hillary Clinton and also her campaign of 2008 started the birther controversy. Ns finished it."


But Trump"s brand-new allegation that it was all Clinton"s fault is as untrue together his initial lie. The public document over the past decade undermines his attempt to blame the democratic nominee because that the beginnings of a conspiracy trump card peddled because that years.

You are watching: Did hillary clinton started the birther movement

People in Clinton"s orbit did comment on Obama"s background throughout their bitter primary struggle in 2008. Yet as nasty together that project got in ~ times, the was no an anything-goes affair. And it shows up that when Clinton gained wind the smears around Obama"s root or religion, she either shut under that heat of argument or ignored it.

There is no evidence that Clinton it s her has ever before said Obama wasn"t born in America.

Trump, meanwhile, was for the past five years the major propagator that the falsehood the Obama was no born in Hawaii in 1961, also though there to be no major question around Obama"s birthplace even prior to the president produced his birth certificate in 2011.


On Sunday, Trump"s project manager, Kellyanne Conway, cited three pieces of proof to assistance her boss" case that Clinton to be the original "birther."

Here"s a closer look at at proof that is dubious at best, stops working to tie the falsehood conclusively to Clinton, and cannot contend with Trump"s multiyear initiative to weaken the legitimacy that the nation"s first African-American president.

___

The email

In an interview Sunday with CBS" "Face The Nation," Conway readily available as a very first piece that evidence an e-mail that surfaced around a month before the January 2008 Iowa caucuses. Obama and also Clinton, then us senators, were at that time locked in a fierce project as stars atop the autonomous presidential field.


Judy Rose, Clinton"s top volunteer in a rural east Iowa county, had actually forwarded the chain email to eight other Democrats. It mentioned the Kenyan ancestry and Muslim belief of Obama"s father. But that email, which became public the following month, claimed "Obama to be born in Honolulu, Hawaii."

The email falsely asserted Obama to be a Muslim and also equated Islam with assistance for overthrowing the united state government. "The Muslims have said they arrangement on destroying the U.S. Indigenous the inside out, what far better way to begin than at the highest level," the email from an anonymous writer stated.

Rose quit she unpaid volunteer post, and also Clinton"s national project manager, Patti Solis Doyle, contacted her equivalent in Obama"s campaign, David Plouffe, to apologize. It to be clear, Obama"s team says, the Clinton was not behind the check smear.

"Having functioned on the campaign, there to be no point where us felt the Hillary Clinton was pushing this rumors," claimed Tommy Vietor, Obama"s 2008 Iowa project spokesman and also later a White House communications aide.


Questions around Obama"s ar of birth did surface ar in an anonymous email in April 2008 the was circulated amongst some die-hard Clinton supporters, as Obama showed up headed toward the presidential nomination.

That email alleged the Obama"s US-born mother was life in Kenya so late in her pregnancy, to be unable come travel, and also registered his bear in Hawaii after ~ he was born. There is no evidence Clinton or her campaign team spread out it around.


*

us President Barack Obama in ~ a news conference at the Landmark Mekong Riverside Hotel in Vientiane, Laos, ~ above September 8 ~ attending the ASEAN Summit. associated Press/Carolyn Kaster

The memo

Conway additionally cited a memo by note Penn, Clinton"s cook pollster and media strategist in the 2008 campaign. The cites Obama"s "Lack the American Roots" together a liability.

"His roots to simple American worths and culture are at best limited," penn wrote, further suggesting Obama was "not in ~ his center fundamentally American in his thinking and also his values." pen went top top to suggest Clinton draw attention to the idea "without walking negative."


In a race that had actually become an individual and caustic, Clinton rejected out of hand the ideas that pen did present, Solis Doyle said.

"I"m not saying us didn"t campaign hard versus Obama," she said. "It was a hard-fought, occasionally brutal campaign. Yet this would have delegitimized his identity. And, to us, that was beyond the pale."

It is worth noting, too, over there is no point out in the strategy proposal that Obama"s birthplace. "We are never going to say anything about his lift — we have actually to present the worth of ours," pen wrote.

The associate

By one account, an essential unofficial torture to Clinton walk stoke rumors about Obama"s nation of birth. Conway cited Clinton combine Sidney Blumenthal conference the Washington bureau chief for McClatchy newspapers at the time, James Asher, and telling him Obama was born in Kenya.


Blumenthal has actually denied pointing out the topic with Asher, who maintains the met v the Clinton confidant. McClatchy correspondents have actually said it"s true Asher asked them come look into Obama"s ties come Kenya. Do the efforts by The associated Press to reach Asher ~ above Tuesday were unsuccessful.

But over there is no dispute that Blumenthal, if close come Clinton, was not officially part of the campaign staff. The McClatchy newspapers found nothing to assistance the claim that Obama was born in Kenya.

See more: The Difference Between Hernia And Sports Hernia Or Inguinal Hernia Or Aps?

Nor go Clinton"s project stir a pot that Trump would have tendency to because that years.

"The "birther" thing was never an problem that mattered in any conversation, rising to the level where we had to resolve it," claimed Paul Tewes, a an elderly Obama campaign adviser in 2008. "In various other words, i don"t believe the Clinton campaign was the end there being malicious."