What go Hillary Clinton know about the Russia uranium deal? dorn question. (Photo by Cindy... <+> Ord/Getty photos for Women"s Media Center)

Hillary Clinton is back in the news. However the reason is a large nothing burger.

You are watching: Did hillary clinton sell russia uranium

In a 2015 book, Breitbart News editor Peter Schweizer asserted that donations to the Clinton foundation were behind the Obama administration’s approval ofthe 2010sale of a Canadian mining agency to a Russian state-controlled firm. The sale offered Russia control of a large swath of American uranium interests.

And by large, us really typical small.

Theallegations are back in the newsafter a report in The Hill critical weekclaimed,citing cotton sources, that at the moment U.S.officialswere weighing whether to provide the deal, the FBIwas investigatingevidence ofbribery, kickbacks, extortion and money launderingby Russian nuclear sector officialsdesigned to aid further Russian chairman Vladimir Putin"scommercial nuclear ambitions within the joined States.

The Hill short article was seized on through right-wing media ― and also the president ― as evidence backing increase a conspiracy theory that they"ve thrust amid the investigations into Russia"s initiatives to swing the presidential choice toDonaldTrump. The genuine collusion scandal, castle claim, involves Russia and also Hillary Clinton. The implicit of the item is thatthe FBI examination should have been well-known to those that approved the transaction in question.

Clinton"sState Department and also several federal government agencies ~ above the Committee on international Investment in the United claims unanimously approved the 2010 partial sale of Canadian mining agency Uranium One come the Russian nuclear huge Rosatom, supposedly offering Moscow regulate of much more than 20% the America’s uranium supply.

Obama and Clinton colluding come hand over 20% America’s strategy uranium come the Russians? ~ above cue, Fox News gabber Sean Hannity said this can be "the greatest scandal" in American history.

But here"s the thing ― by 20%, we really mean virtually zero.

Those U.S. Facilities derived by Russia produce practically nothing. The uranium deposits room of reasonably poor grade and are as well costly to complete on the uranium market. But the infrastructure do have good milling volume to procedure ore, if anyone gives it come them, i m sorry hasn’t occurred in around 10 years. Theoretically, castle could process 20% of our ore, however that will never ever happen. Uranium One couldn’t provide these infrastructure away.

Besides, Russia can not export any uranium they develop in the U.S. They execute not own a atom Regulatory commission export license.

The real reason Russia want this deal was to give Rosatom’s subsidiary Uranium One"s very lucrative uranium mines in Kazakhstan ― the solitary largest producer of commercial uranium in the world.

Then, in 2011, the administration approved a Rosatom subsidiary to market commercial uranium to U.S. Nuclear power plants in partnership through the U.S. Enrichment Corporation. Up until then, Russia had actually been minimal to offering our nuclear power plants uranium reprocessed from old Soviet nuclear weapons under the 1990s Megatons come Megawatts tranquility program. Nothing strange here, either. Finally, in 2013, Russia obtained 100% attention in Uranium One.

Rather 보다 take action against this deal, the department of righteousness just continued investigating the matter for years, essentially leaving the American public, Congress, the secretary that state and the management in the dark about much more Russian meddling in the unified States, this time including nuclear.

Candidate trump jumped on this problem during the 2016 project trail last year, yet as secretary the state, Clinton to be not involved in the committee reviewand never ever intervened ~ above the matter, and there to be several various other agencies involved in the recommendation.

It is still no clear why nobody at the FBI alerted the Obama administration to the Russian kickbacks, extortion threats and money laundering before these decisions to be made. One concept is that the United says was still seeking come "reset" its connection with Russia and also was also trying to get Putin top top board through our Iran atom deal. Yet in the end, this Russian deal simply wasn’t that important and also had no national security ramifications.

As Jeffrey Lewis, a atom nonproliferation experienced at the Middlebury Institute, defined it, Russia’s acquisition of the firm "had as much of an influence on nationwide security together it would have if they set the money on fire. That’s most likely why (all the U.S. Organ involved) authorized it."

The key to this issue’s resurgence this mainly is that Hillary Clinton to be secretary that state in ~ the time, bill Clinton was getting rewarding speaking fees in Russia, and Russian money was finding its method to the Clinton Foundation, back the amount transforms out to be small. However, even if there was no wrongdoing ~ above the component of the management or the Clintons, and also no nationwide security reason for anyone to oppose this deal, some still desire to make it an additional Benghazi.

As a scandal, this worry lacks relevance since Clinton is currently a personal citizen and also Russian meddling in our 2016 election has end up being a bigger issue. In fact, every the attention now being paid to the uranium deal seems to have much more to do with Robert Mueller’s current investigationof Russian collusion than through Clinton.

The political ramifications aside, what is the truth of ours uranium supplies, and also how lot does Russian meddling affect them?

Short prize – no at all.

There’s lots and lots the uranium in the world, and much more keeps being discovered. Simply look in ~ the 2017 AAPG EMD Committee Report the covers uranium, various other nuclear minerals and rare planet elements.

According to the command author, Michael Campbell in ~ I2M Associates, "we room awash in uranium, not to point out all power minerals – oil, coal and especially natural gas." (Disclosure: ns am a member of that committee and a co-author of the report.)

This is especially true in phibìc America, which includes the highest-grade uranium store in the world. TheAthabasca container of Saskatchewan is recognized as the "Saudi Arabia of Uranium."

Which is crucial since we need to dual nuclear strength to deal with climate readjust and change coal, also as we ramp increase renewables. We likewise need to administer an extra 300 exchange rate kWhs every year to fee the 100-million-plus fleet of totally electric vehicles America needs by 2040 to have any type of chance of putting a genuine dent in our petroleum use.

So yes, north America is essentially uranium-independent. And also no, this Russian deal had, and will have, no impact, beside from showing that the FBI is lax in its beginning of Russians who break our laws, and lax in alerting us to your meddling gradually to execute anything about it.

See more: Does Cooking Meat Kill All Bacteria, Bending The Rules On Bacteria And Food Safety


I have been a scientist in the ar of the earth and also environmental sciences for 33 years, specializing in geologic disposal of nuclear waste, energy-related research, planetary surface ar processes, radiobiology and shielding for room colonies, subsurface transport and also environmental clean-up of heavy metals. Ns am a Trustee that the Herbert M. Parker Foundation, Adjunct in ~ WSU, an Affiliate Scientist at LANL and also consult on strategic planning for the DOE, EPA/State ecological agencies, and also industry including companies that own nuclear, hydro, wind farms, huge solar arrays, coal and gas plants. I additionally consult because that EPA/State environmental agencies and industry on clean-up of heavy metals native soil and also water. For over 25 years I have been a member the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, the NRDC, the eco-friendly Defense Fund and also many others, as well as professional societies consisting of the America atom Society, the American chemistry Society, the Geological culture of America and the American combination of Petroleum Geologists.