No, Clinton didn't start the birther thing. This guy did.

You are watching: Did hillary clinton questions obama’s citizenship

Despite what trump card says, the 2008 Clinton campaign and also the candidate herself never trafficked in the rumors.


Trump diversity director: Obama birther concerns 'not a gyeongju thing'

is roots to an easy American worths and culture are at ideal limited,” penn wrote. “I can not imagine electing a president throughout a time of battle who is no at his center fundamentally American in his thinking and also in his values.”

The Clinton campaign never work Penn’s strategy, and to this day it provokes sharply various perceptions amongst those that remember discussing it. Two sources with expertise of the deliberations to speak Penn’s memo brought about a “near-staff revolt” at the time it come up and contributed come factional infighting that would later on hobble the campaign.

Another resource who recalled the discussion dismissed the perception as revisionist, suggesting instead that the memo to be barely taken into consideration at all. “This memo got about 30 secs of discussion and also the just recommendation was that she emphasize her Midwest upbringing,” the resource said. “While the project may have actually disagreed top top going negative on Barack Obama, this paragraph had actually nothing to carry out with those discussions and also it did no in any kind of cause any type of discussion the his citizenship.”

Later, in the feather 2008, together Clinton’s opportunities of win the democratic primary prospered thin, few of her hardcore supporters circulated rumors the Obama might not it is in a U.S. Citizen, picking up on some of Martin’s innuendo and also extending the further.

“Barack Obama’s mom was life in Kenya through his Arab-African father so late in she pregnancy. She to be not permitted to take trip by aircraft then, so Barack Obama was born there and his mom then take it him come Hawaii to register his birth,” read one of those emails posted, at the time, through, a website that attempts come debunk net rumors.


On Friday, Clinton’s former an elderly aide Patti Solis Doyle acknowledged that a volunteer coordinator in Iowa forwarded a birther-related email. “Hillary make the decision immediately let that human go,” she said. “We allow that person go. It was so past the pale that the campaign Hillary want to run and that we as a employee wanted to run that I called David Plouffe that was controlling Barack Obama to apologize come say this is not coming native us, the this was rogue volunteer.”

“The project nor Hillary walk not start the birther movement, period,” she said.

The rumors the Obama to be born in Kenya dogged him together he entered the basic election fight versus John McCain (who similarly steered clear of the issue). Some conservative blogs picked up the rumor as well. To counter the claim, the Obama project released a copy that his short-form “certification that live birth” come the liberal everyday Kos.

But that was that gesture that showed the durability of the birther conspiracy theories. Immediately, those who wondered about Obama’s birth declared the short-form birth certificate poor proof or also a forgery. But the issue had clearly moved also further come the fringe and seemed to dissipate until Donald Trump revived it in 2011, demanding a “long-form” bear certificate.


During a in march 23, 2011 illustration on The View, trump sparred v Whoopi Goldberg and also Barbara Walters around Obama’s birth.

“Why doesn’t he display his bear certificate?” trump said. “I great he would because I think it’s a destructive pall it is hanging over him … yes sir something on that birth certificate that he doesn’t like.”

When panelists inquiry Trump why George W. Bush was never asked to produce his bear certificate, trumped added, “I’m not saying ns a pan of George Bush. You recognize that much better than anybody. But George bush was born in this country.”

For the next couple of months, trump card courted believers in the conspiracy and also even advised proponents for state laws requiring future presidents to create proof of their U.S. Birth. Ironically, one Arizona invoice on the matter, which Trump specifically supported for, to be vetoed by then-Gov. January Brewer – now a optimal Trump surrogate. Brewer wondered about its requirement to pressure presidential candidates to relax “baptismal or circumcision certificates” in lieu the a bear certificate.

At the time, polling showed Republicans to be far an ext inclined to think that Obama wasn’t a U.S. Citizen. At the time, as they perform now, the Clintons forcefully disavowed the notion.

See more: Does Chris Cuomo Have The Coronavirus : Coronavirus Updates : Npr

Glenn Thrush and Brent Griffiths added reporting.

A brief history of Donald Trump's birther past

On Friday, Donald trump card officially proclaimed that the no much longer believes president Barack Obama was born outside the unified States, breaking far from a conspiracy concept that aided fuel his politics rise.