The presumptive autonomous nominee has actually made a variety of comments that show up to clash v the FBI’s result after its email investigation


Hillary Clinton has said her use of a personal email server ‘wasn’t the best choice’. Photograph: Susan Walsh/AP
Hillary Clinton has actually said her use of a private email server ‘wasn’t the best choice’. Photograph: Susan Walsh/AP

The FBI has recommended no charges against Hillary Clinton, the presumptive autonomous nominee because that president, even though agents go find straight contradictions, misleading claims and falsehoods in assertions make by Clinton and also her campaign around her use of a private email server while secretary that state.

You are watching: Did hillary break the law with private email

These statements elide the truth: some usage of personal email is allowed but Clinton offered private servers exclusively, and also broke rules in the process, according to a state department inspector general report in May and FBI manager James Comey ~ above Tuesday.

Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama prefer the elephant come the emails in the room
Read more
The state department report uncovered that Clinton had actually violated rules in her usage of the personal system: she did no conduct day-to-day company on a room channel, did no consult information and security officers around the server, and also skirted the rules of records preservation requests. ~ above Tuesday, Comey called her methods “extremely careless” and also said: “None of these emails should have actually been on any kind of unclassified server.”

The FBI director additionally warned that in comparable circumstances offenders space “often topic to security or bureaucratic sanctions”.

The FBI investigation uncovered Clinton’s assertion to be false: agents found 110 emails to be classified at the moment they were sent or received, Comey stated on Tuesday. Eight of those emails had “top secret” information at the time, 36 included “secret” information, and eight had actually “confidential” information. About 2,000 emails that were not significant classified at the moment were later on upgraded to confidential.

Comey lent a small amount of credence to Clinton’s defense that product was not “marked” classified, but his declare was much more damning than not. “Only a very small number of the emails comprise classified info bore markings denote the existence of classified information,” that said.

“But even if info is not significant ‘classified’ in an email, attendees who understand or should recognize that the subject matter is classified are still mandatory to protect it.”

Colin Powell supplied a an individual email deal with when he to be secretary that state from 2001 to 2005, and it is not uncommon for federal government officials to sometimes use exclusive email addresses. Prefer Clinton, Powell used private email exclusively, but he go not use a exclusive server and also government rule were not well identified during his tenure. In spite of this, the state room still ruled in its recent report that he go not preserve email records.

Condoleezza Rice and also Madeleine Albright, two other secretaries of state prior to Clinton, did not use exclusive or official email because that state department work. Clinton’s successor, john Kerry, infrequently uses personal email come respond to people who call him there, follow to the report.

Clinton offered 30,940 emails to the state department in December 2014, after she lawyers searched the archives for product relating to federal government work. She has actually said that she deleted an ext than 31,000 an individual emails that were likewise on her servers.

FBI investigators found no proof that any kind of work-related emails “were purposely deleted in an initiative to conceal them”, Comey said.

But the FBI found “several thousand work emails that were no in the team of 30,000” offered by Clinton come the state department, Comey said, after ~ agents searched with devices associated to the private server and also on archived federal government accounts. He additionally said that Clinton and also her staff appeared to periodically delete emails, like many email users, and also that she lawyers sifted through the emails by subject lines and search terms, definition they more than likely missed some occupational emails.

Comey added that some emails probably remain undiscovered or lost forever, in part for technical reasons. Once servers were decommissioned in 2013, for instance, millions of email pieces were scattered in “slack space”, follow to Comey, leaving a “jigsaw puzzle” behind for agents to sort through.

Clinton’s project has said the justice department made “a protection referral” that “was not criminal in nature together misreported by part in the press”. This language misleadingly suggests the FBI was only investigating to see whether Clinton’s email servers were at danger of protection breaches and also hacking.

Comey do clear the the examination by FBI agents did search for criminal conduct, even if they eventually did not find evidence that “willful mishandling”, “indications the disloyalty come the unified States”, obstruction of justice or “vast amounts of product exposed”.

See more: What Is Creatine And What Does Creatine Fill Your Muscles With Water Retention

“We cannot discover a case that would support bringing criminal fees on this facts,” the said. “To it is in clear, this is not to imply that in comparable circumstances, a human being who involved in this task would face no consequences. To the contrary, those people are often subject to security or governmental sanctions. However that is not what we space deciding now.”

Comey claimed that Clinton not only used multiple servers but likewise “used countless mobile tools to view and send email” making use of her an individual account, undercutting she justification.